Why so many admire Elon Musk. It goes back to adolescence.
Iconfess to a voyeuristic reflex that makes me glance at headlines about Elon Musk and Twitter, as I might rubberneck when passing a car wreck. Will they self-destruct? Will they turn things around against all odds?
It goes back to a feeling I had when I was in my late teens and devouring Ayn Rand novels. Rand’s protagonists, such as the architect Howard Roark in “The Fountainhead” or the Capitalist Übermensch John Galt in “Atlas Shrugged,” are cartoons of what Musk and his ilk aspire to be.
They’re uncompromising, ultramasculine and hyper-individualistic visionaries. They’re in it for themselves, powered by an unapologetic egocentrism that rejects the serf morality of ordinary people. That might explain why Tesla founder Musk, Amazon titan Jeff Bezos and quite a few other hard-driving — and almost invariably male — tech tycoons adulate Ayn Rand.
In this worldview, anybody who doesn’t grasp the singleminded genius of a Roark, Galt, Musk or Bezos belongs to the naysaying mediocrities and bureaucrats, the socialists and parasites, the unproductive and disingenuous slouches and “moochers,” the cowards and conformists.
Roark’s vision is an ideal of sleek and simple architecture that make the human spirit soar, but for that very reason can’t be appreciated by lesser mortals condemned to being spiritual pygmies. Musk’s vision is an almost eschatological iteration of Roark’s. His big idea is to prepare humanity’s escape from our home planet by colonizing Mars.
Musk co-founded one company, SpaceX, to build the rockets that will one day transport us to Mars, with the accompanying satellite communications (Starlink) we’ll need. He has another, the Boring Company, that drills tunnels, so that we can live and zip around under Mars’ surface to avoid the radiation. He runs another, Tesla, that will harness sunlight to move us around. To get our human cognition up to snuff for these adventures, Musk nurses Neuralink, which dabbles in brain implants.
By now it should be clear why Roarks, Galts or Musks capture the imaginations of teenage boys like the one I used to be, or the one still hiding inside me now. They rebel against — and burst — the limits of the humdrum and stultifying mainstream. They’re heroic, and romantic. We root for them. We fantasize about being them.
But as boys grow up, some also mature — even I, in my mere fifties, am feeling the beginnings of that process. Attempts to reread Rand reveal her characters to be one-dimensional and flat. The boy’s imagination flared at their oratory; the middle-aged man nods off during speechifying that goes on for pages of repetitive cliches.
The mature re-reader makes several observations. First, Rand was a mediocre writer. Second, her characters are actually boring. Third, the plots that wannabe Roarks and Galts such as Musk try to emulate are destined to meet a fate worse than failure: prosaic reality.
In that real world, Tesla turns into just another car company, which its first-generation employees eventually leave in disappointment. The Boring Company actually becomes boring. SpaceX seems self-indulgent. Neuralink is science fiction.
As for Twitter, it’s just a site where media types like me curate their work while mobs of trolls and bots cast aspersions and spread conspiracy theories. Normal people needn’t waste time on it.
As for Musk, what initially looked like romantic intensity suddenly just looks sadomasochistic. Sure, he brags about how he sleeps on the office floors of his companies because he works so hard. And he demands that his covisionaries do the same. So he fires half of Twitter’s employees, then emails the rest, in the middle of the night, challenging them to be “hardcore” or get the heck off his spaceship.
Those employees aren’t Randian moochers. In their own ways, they may be just as talented and idealistic as Musk. But they also have families, lives and bills to pay. They’ll be forgiven for rolling their eyes.
And so Rand’s lure over the teenager recedes. Musk, Roark and Galt start looking like yet more men succumbing to hubris and getting trapped in a desperate solipsism. How will they react?
When a kitsch architect messes with his genius construction, a public-housing project, Roark dynamites it. No poor family will ever live there. When Galt has enough of the moochers, he gathers all the country’s great inventors and creators and goes on strike in Galt’s gulch, somewhere in Colorado, until the outside world is a wasteland. Musk, too, may yet find his own way to blow up Twitter, or much more.
This isn’t the romantic heroism of creative genius yearning to soar free. It’s the sugar crash of narcissists wandering off on ego trips, throwing temper tantrums and storming out in rage quits. There are more important things deserving my attention.