Judge fines Trump $5K for violating gag order
NEW YORK — Former President Donald Trump was fined $5,000 on Friday after his disparaging social media post about a key court staffer in his New York civil fraud trial lingered on his campaign website for weeks after the judge ordered it deleted.
Judge Arthur Engoron avoided holding Mr. Trump in contempt for now, but reserved the right to do so — and possibly even put the 2024 Republican front-runner in jail — if he again violates a limited gag order barring case participants from personal attacks on court staff.
Judge Engoron said in a written ruling that he is “way beyond the ‘warning’ stage,” but that he was only fining Mr. Trump a nominal amount because this was a “first time violation” and Mr. Trump’s lawyers said the website’s retention of the post had been inadvertent.
“Make no mistake: future violations, whether intentional or unintentional, will subject the violator to far more severe sanctions, which may include steeper financial penalties, holding Donald Trump in contempt of court, and possibly imprisoning him,” Judge Engoron wrote in a two-page order.
A campaign spokesman didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment on the ruling.
Trump lawyer Christopher Kise earlier blamed the “very large machine” of Mr. Trump’s White House campaign for allowing the post to remain on the website after Mr. Trump had deleted it from social media, as ordered, calling it an unintentional oversight. It was removed from the website late Thursday after Judge Engoron flagged it to Mr. Trump’s lawyers.
Mr. Trump wasn’t in court Friday. He’d been at the trial Tuesday and Wednesday after attending the first three days in early October. Outside court this week, he aimed his enmity at Judge Engoron and New York Attorney General Letitia James, whose fraud lawsuit is
being decided at the civil trial. Neither are covered by Judge Engoron’s gag order.
Judge Engoron, however, said the buck ultimately stops with Mr. Trump — even if it was someone on his campaign who failed to remove the offending post. He gave Mr. Trump 10 days to pay the fine.
“I want to be clear that Donald Trump is still responsible for the large machine even if it’s a large machine,” Judge Engoron said after discussing the matter with Mr. Trump’s lawyers before testimony resumed Friday morning.
Judge Engoron issued a limited gag order Oct. 3 barring all participants in the case from smearing his staff after Mr. Trump maligned principal law clerk Allison Greenfield in a post on Mr. Trump’s Truth Social platform. The judge ordered Mr. Trump to delete the post, which made a baseless insinuation about the clerk’s personal life, and warned of “serious sanctions” for violations.
“In the current overheated climate, incendiary untruths can, and in some cases already have, led to serious physical harm, and worse,” Judge Engoron wrote Friday.
Before Mr. Trump deleted the post from Truth Social, as ordered, his campaign copied the message into an email blast. That email, with the subject line “ICYMI,” was automatically archived on Mr. Trump’s website, Mr. Kise said.
The email was sent to about 25,800 recipients on the campaign’s media list and opened by about 6,700 of them, Mr. Kise told Judge Engoron after obtaining the statistics at the morning break. In all, only 3,700 people viewed the post on Mr. Trump’s campaign website, the lawyer said.
“What happened appears truly inadvertent,” Mr. Kise said. The lawyer pleaded ignorance to the technological complexities involved in amplifying Mr. Trump’s social media posts and public statements, calling the archiving “an unfortunate part of the campaign process.”
New York law allows judges to impose fines or imprisonment as punishment for contempt. Last year, Judge Engoron held Mr. Trump in contempt and fined him $110,000 for being slow to respond to a subpoena in the investigation that led to the lawsuit.
Ms. James’ lawsuit accuses Mr. Trump and his company of duping banks and insurers by giving them heavily inflated statements of Mr. Trump’s net worth and asset values. Judge Engoron has already ruled that Mr. Trump and his company committed fraud, but the trial involves remaining claims of conspiracy, insurance fraud and falsifying business records.
Mr. Trump denies wrongdoing, arguing that a disclaimer on his financial statements absolves him of any culpability and that some of his assets are worth far more than what’s listed on the documents. He has called the trial a “sham,” a “scam” and “a continuation of the single greatest witch hunt of all time.”
Mr. Trump and his two eldest sons, Eric and Donald Trump Jr., are expected to testify in a few weeks. His daughter Ivanka Trump is fighting a subpoena for her testimony. Judge Engoron set a hearing on that dispute for next week.