Press-Telegram (Long Beach)

Why are there antitrust cases pursued against Google?

- — B.G., Torrance — B.G., Torrance Ron Sokol is a Manhattan Beach attorney with more than 35 years of experience. His column, which appears in print on Wednesdays, presents a summary of the law and should not be construed as legal advice. Email questions a

QTwo questions: First, Google is being sued on a number of fronts for so-called antitrust violations, but in my view, Google provides a lot of really good services and employs a lot of people. Is “just too big” the issue?

AAntitrust prohibitio­ns are found in federal and state laws that seek to regulate the conduct and organizati­on of business entities, with the focus on promoting competitio­n and preventing monopolies. Google, the well-known search engine, faces litigation brought by state and federal enforcers.

For example, the U.S. Department of Justice is pursuing a case that argues Google utilizes anticompet­itive tactics to protect its monopoly over general search activities.

Another litigation, brought by a coalition over 30 states, makes a similar argument but includes further allegation­s, the most significan­t of which is that Google utilizes its control over general searches (Googling) to discrimina­te against other companies in the vertical search business (for example, Yelp or

Kayak).

This means that Google wants us to begin all searches on Google, not otherwise. Google vigorously contests these cases, and there is quite a ways to go to see how they play out. It is not so much that “too big” is the issue. It is whether “too big” means too much snuffing out of others, done in such a way that trade and commerce are truly obstructed.

QSecond question: There are antitrust bills now in the U.S. Congress to revamp the likes of Amazon, Apple, Google and Facebook. What is going on there?

The donation to LBCC is unrestrict­ed, the college said. But it will be prioritize­d for three areas, including:

• Improving student academic outcomes by addressing racial equity gaps.

• Promoting an inclusive and affirming campus environmen­t.

• Increasing holistic support services for our most vulnerable students.

“We are grateful for this generous gift to Long Beach City College’s equity and racial justice work,” Uduak-Joe Ntuk, the Board of Trustees president for the Long Beach Community College District, said in a statement. “These funds will expand on that work to accelerate academic outcomes, increase economic opportunit­y and expand upward mobility for generation­s of LBCC students.”

The vast majority of LBCC’s student population are people of color, with more than 58% identifyin­g as Latino. Students who are Asian, Native American and Pacific Islander comprise 11% of the population. Black students also make up 11% of LBCC’s population.

ADrafts of antitrust bills that might reshape popular business models for the Big Tech companies are being circulated. This follows a yearlong investigat­ion by the House Judiciary subcommitt­ee on antitrust, focusing on Amazon, Apple, Google and Facebook. A nearly 450-page report was produced.

The draft bills have various features, including limiting the ability of the four companies to complete large mergers, requiring each to make it easier for users to leave their platforms with their data intact, and preventing them from owning businesses that present a conflict of interest. Bottom line, as

Among the initiative­s and successes LBCC touted in its Tuesday announceme­nt were increasing overall transfers to four-year universiti­es by 16% over the last three years, including 51% and 19% increases among Black and Latino students, respective­ly.

The number of Black students going from high school to LBCC increased 25% from fall 2019 to fall 2020.

And in the last five years, the number of Black and Latino students receiving degrees from LBCC increased 119% and 125%, respective­ly, the college said.

The college last year, in the wake of George Floyd being killed and nationwide protests against systemic racism, adopted the Long Beach Framework of Reconcilia­tion in Support of the Black Community. That initiative is meant to address institutio­nal racism at LBCC.

“It hasn’t been easy to have those hard and uncomforta­ble conversati­ons about institutio­nal racism within Long Beach City College,” interim Superinten­dentPresid­ent Dr. Mike Muñoz said in a statement. “We acknowledg­ed with the lawsuits against Google, stay tuned.

One question that clearly presents itself: By purporting to rein in these businesses, are we instead hurting the market place and not letting full-on competitio­n play itself out?

that we need to dismantle the barriers that sometime prevents our most vulnerable students from succeeding. These courageous efforts made by our students and employees and led by our Board of Trustees are being recognized and validated. I hope this gift inspires

FDA as of today, but have received Emergency Use Authorizat­ion. Thus, you are first to be informed you are not required to take the shot. In turn, an employer has a level of discretion to terminate an employee whose employment is at-will. Just how this will be dealt with going forward carries some uncertaint­y for the time being. those who may be uncertain about changing the status quo to join our institutio­nal movement from being color blind to a race conscious approach.”

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States