New film explores abortion dilemma on border

Nearly halfway into “On the Divide,” a documentary about the last abortion clinic left along Texas’ border with Mexico, Rey Guerrero — a security guard in his 60s who protects the entryway to Whole Woman’s Health — kneels at an altar and prays.

He asks God to protect the patients he shields from antiabortion protesters who, with rosaries in hand, beg them to continue with their pregnancies.

“Sometimes they cross the line,” Guerrero says in the film, referring to the religious antiabortion protesters. “They come to insult the girls and make it worse and they go deeper into depression by the things they say.”

Guerrero is Catholic. He prays every day, but he doesn’t go to church. The church, he says in the film, turned him away ever since he began working at the abortion clinic. He’d hear churchgoers whispering, “Look, he kills babies.”

“They call me a murderer,” Guerrero says.

“On the Divide,” which premiered April 18 on PBS and is streaming on pov.org free until May 18, follows the stories of the people surrounding Whole Woman’s Health of McAllen, the only abortion clinic available in the Rio Grande Valley — a region of 1.4 million, mostly Spanish-speaking residents. The Catholic-based McAllen Pregnancy Center is right next to the abortion clinic.

The film comes after Texas passed one of the most restrictive abortion laws in the country and as the Supreme Court is reportedly expected to abolish Roe v. Wade as suggested by a leaked draft majority opinion published in Politico.

The film explores how religion informs the response of Latinos along the U.S.-Mexico border on issues surrounding abortion.

It features Mercedes Soto, once involved in gangs and an

avid supporter of the pregnancy center, who prays the rosary outside the abortion clinic; Denisse Gonzalez, a young mother of four who volunteers at Whole Woman’s Health and helps guide women into the clinic; and Guerrero, who throughout the film finds himself defending his faith to protesters outside the clinic.

“On The Divide” has been screening in cities across the country just as news of Lizelle Herrera’s arrest made nationwide headlines. The 26-yearold Rio Grande Valley woman was charged with murder over what sheriffs alleged was a “selfinduced abortion.” The charge was dropped and Herrera has been freed. Texas law exempts pregnant people from criminal homicide charges for an abortion. South Texans for Reproductive Justice, a civil rights alliance featured in the documentary, was among those who sounded the alarm about her arrest.

To the film’s directors, Maya Cueva and Leah Galant, it was difficult, yet not surprising, to hear about the circumstances surrounding the abortion. They began filming the documentary seven years ago.

“On the Divide” emerged after Cueva and Galant worked on a short film about a traveling abortion doctor in Texas while they were still at Ithaca College in New York. As they continued to spend time in the border region, they connected with another traveling doctor at Whole Woman’s Health who introduced them to clinic workers, residents and organizers in the Rio Grande Valley.

“As soon as we got there we saw that (religion) was a really heavy presence,” Cueva told Religion News Service.

Cueva, a Latina filmmaker, aims to show that Latinos are not monolithic, partly by capturing the role religion plays in their views on abortion.

She hopes others can grasp that you can be religious and “continue to fight for the right to choose.”

“Religion does really play a big role in this and we can’t just overlook it,” Cueva said.

Galant, who is Jewish, said they sought to go beyond the “one side or another” debate and show that “we’re all complicated, nuanced individuals.”

“We want to expand what people think, when they think of who has a stake in reproductive justice, and how it relates to religion,” Galant said. “In sharing these stories that don’t really fall into a binary polarizing viewpoint, you can’t help but expand your worldview on what it means to be part of religion and/or to fight for reproductive freedom.”

Catholics for Choice, which opposes the church’s official stance against abortion, is a partner in the film’s impact campaign. Marlee Breakstone, a coordinator with Catholics for Choice, said in a virtual conversation with the filmmakers that Catholics know they “are called to protect the health rights and consciences of all of their neighbors.”

The film, Breakstone said, “shows how closely a person’s faith is tied to every decision they make.”

It follows Soto, who calls herself a “prayer warrior,” as she goes from praying her rosary outside the abortion clinic to grappling with her Catholic faith when she acquires contraceptives from a free clinic to prevent another pregnancy. Soto said her son was “saved from abortion” by a sidewalk counselor who convinced her to continue with her pregnancy.

“Sometimes I feel I can’t turn to the church because of what it is,” she says. “The Catholic Church is always going to be there during the day. Once the light goes away and the darkness comes out, who’s going to be there?”