San Diego Union-Tribune

ISRAEL’S TOP COURT TO REVIEW JUDICIAL OVERHAUL

-

Israel’s Supreme Court said Wednesday that it would begin in September to review a contentiou­s new law that diminishes the court’s own role, setting the stage for a constituti­onal crisis and renewed social turmoil if the judges then overturn the legislatio­n.

The decision sets up a looming clash between the executive branch of government and the highest court in the land. The Supreme Court must now decide whether to reassert its dominance over Prime Minister Benjamin’s Netanyahu’s government — or it must accept the move to reduce its own power.

Either conclusion is likely to provoke widespread anger, since the issue has become a proxy for a much broader battle over Israel’s character.

The court’s announceme­nt came in response to the decision on Monday, by Netanyahu’s coalition, to pass a deeply divisive bill that stops the court from overruling government decisions with the legal standard of “reasonable­ness.” The government said the term, never defined in a statute, was too subjective and gave unelected judges too much leeway to overrule elected lawmakers.

The bitter debate over the law has widened Israel’s social fissures into profound divides. Large parts of society fear the change will remove a key check on Netanyahu’s government — the most nationalis­t and religiousl­y conservati­ve in Israeli history — and allow it to gradually turn Israel into a less pluralist and more conservati­ve country.

It led several opposition groups to petition the court to use its remaining powers to overturn the law.

On Wednesday afternoon, the court announced on its website that it would hear two of the petitions in September. An exact date has yet to be set, and the court did not announce which of its 15 judges would hear the petitions or how long the process would last. The court often takes weeks if not months to reach a decision.

If the court strikes down the law, Netanyahu’s government will be forced to decide whether to respect the decision of an institutio­n that it is trying to restrain. And should the government reject the court’s ruling, Israel’s other key institutio­ns — its military, police, civil service and lower courts — will in turn need to decide whether to obey the country’s executive or judicial branch.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States