San Francisco Chronicle - (Sunday)
California students should strike for better treatment
Dear California kids: Don’t let us adults destroy your futures! This time of “distance learning” and COVID19 chaos is the opportunity of a generation — maybe a century — to fix what’s so very wrong with how California treats kids. And right now, you have unprecedented power. I am begging you to use it.
Before COVID19, California wasn’t doing well by its 9.1 million residents under age 18. Now in crisis, the state’s adults are conspiring, without your input, to make things even worse for you. By June’s end, your governor and Legislature will likely pass a budget that cuts a record $15.1 billion from your schools, further hurts the economy, and guts other programs essential to your growth.
You may think that you can do nothing to stop this — after all, you are being ignored as politicians and powerful adult interests make decisions about your future. It doesn’t have to be this way. Right now, with schools shut because of the pandemic, California’s children and teens have more leverage than ever before.
This leverage comes from the fact that education can’t restart in California without your consent. If you kids act together, you have the power to keep the schools shut down. This applies to distance learning, which can’t work if you refuse to sign on to the internet, as well as to physical school reopenings, which can’t happen until you agree to walk back onto those campuses.
Your advantage is not just practical. It’s moral. School districts — having thrown you into hastily organized online classes that left you with massive learning loss — can no longer pretend they have your best interests at heart. But your greatest power is financial. California school funding is based on daily attendance. If you stay home, or refuse to open educational apps, school districts, already in fiscal crisis, will shut down. They won’t get funding if you are absent.
So, as the father of three of you, I’d like to suggest that now, with the budget being written, is the moment to organize and start pressuring your elders. A studentled movement could dictate the terms of the school return and of funding for education and other children’s programs — if it could credibly threaten a statewide student strike in the fall.
What should your demands be? You should figure those out for yourselves, as you meet online. Given California adults’ record of failing you, you shouldn’t trust any of us, including this columnist, to set your agenda. You already know firsthand that California ranks low in education funding. Who is paying the price for this neglect? You. Fewer than half of you meet state standards in English language arts and mathematics. Only 42% of high school students meet the state’s own criteria for being “prepared” for college. And equity? Your generation has some of the biggest student achievement gaps — based on race and poverty — in our very unequal country.
California leaders love to tout the health insurance coverage they’re providing children, but they rarely mention that you’re not getting enough actual health care. The state ranks especially low on giving kids preventive health screenings, dental care, nutrition assistance, and mental health and substance abuse services.
California is also awful at child care and special education. Elected officials have been promising quality universal preschool for 20 years without delivering it. And there is no state worse than yours at providing sufficient educators, counselors, support staff and administrators for your schools.
The problem in California is not a lack of money — we are rich — or even a lack of good intentions. It’s that adults are selfish and lazy, and refuse to coordinate the different agencies, programs and levels of government that should serve you.
In this extraordinary moment, there are many demands you could make. My suggestion — take it with an adultsize grain of salt — is that you start by saying you won’t return to campus or sign into Google Classroom until all cuts to children’s programs are reversed. Your logic would be simple: Before COVID19, kids were getting systematically screwed in California. During COVID19, your schools are shut and you’re stuck with your families at home. So it’s intolerable that adults are cutting tens of billions of dollars from schools and other programs.
You also might look beyond the current horrors and demand better in the future. Extensive studies have shown that to meet your educational needs, the state should have been spending between 25% and 50% more on schools than it was before COVID19. You could demand that the state, starting next year, fund schools based on educational goals. That would mean eliminating the current Proposition 98 formula, which bases school funding on tax revenues and economic growth.
You also might consider demanding your democratic rights. This year, because it’s the centennial of women’s suffrage, you may have heard about celebrations of “universal suffrage.” What about suffrage for children? It isn’t a wild idea. Countries around the world have elected youth parliaments In fact, children have already made changes in the way our state works. The most successful youthled organization here might be California Youth Connection — a group of foster children who have worked with adults to secure recent reforms to the child welfare system.
Of course, some adults will dismiss you as immature for threatening not to return to school. Ignore them. Adults are already making that very same threat. Just last week, the superintendents of six large school districts — L.A., San Diego, Long Beach, San Francisco, Oakland and Sacramento — threatened to not reopen schools in the fall unless they get more money from the state.
A little political advice. Don’t bother with challenging your local school board or principal. Train all your fire on Gov. Gavin Newsom. The governor has neartotal power on budgeting, and he won his office on a platform of investing in children, from “cradle to college.”
I want to put your mind at ease about one thing. If you have to strike in the fall, you don’t have to stop getting an education. Many schools around the country have developed excellent distancelearning curricula — better than what you’ll find in California — and offered them for free online. And with greater choice comes more power. Use that power. The only people who can save California’s kids are California’s kids.
Sincerely,
Joe Mathews
Joe Mathews writes the Connecting California column for Zócalo Public Square.
My suggestion is that you start by saying you won’t return to campus or sign into Google Classroom until all cuts to children’s programs are reversed.