San Francisco Chronicle

WHO urged to warn of airborne spread

- By Aidin Vaziri Aidin Vaziri is a San Francisco Chronicle staff writer. Email: avaziri@sfchronicl­e.com

Scientists have long contended that the coronaviru­s can linger in the air.

The World Health Organizati­on on Tuesday agreed to formally acknowledg­e the threat aerosols play in the transmissi­on of the virus that causes COVID19 in indoor spaces, after receiving an open letter put forward by 239 researcher­s in 32 countries.

WHO agency scientists said during a news briefing that they would review evidence on transmissi­on of the virus and update its recommenda­tions accordingl­y in a few days.

In an open letter published by the Oxford Academic scientific journal Monday, the group of scientists accuses the internatio­nal health agency of ignoring evidence that microscopi­c particles are released during exhalation that remain aloft in the air and travel further than the establishe­d 6foot physically distancing guidelines set for indoor spaces such as offices, markets, restaurant­s, stores and other businesses.

“We appeal to the medical community and to the relevant national and internatio­nal bodies to recognize the potential for airborne spread of COVID19,” the letter reads.

Until Tuesday, the WHO maintained that the virus is spread primarily by large respirator­y droplets, released when an infected person coughs or sneezes, that fall to the ground; or by touching a contaminat­ed surface and then touching your face.

“Airborne transmissi­on is the fourth factor,” said Mark R. Cullen, founding director of the Center for Population Health Sciences at Stanford University. “There’s a big debate as how important it should be.”

In its latest coronaviru­s update, published June 29, the WHO dismissed the possibilit­y of airborne transmissi­on, except for inside health care settings. The agency asserted that hand washing and social distancing are the most effective ways to curb the spread of the virus.

Dr. Benedetta Allegranzi, who leads the WHO’s committee on infection prevention and control, on Tuesday reconsider­ed that conclusion, saying that aerosol spread in “crowded, closed, poorly ventilated settings, cannot be ruled out.”

The letter presented by Lidia Morawska, a professor of atmospheri­c sciences and environmen­tal engineerin­g at the Queensland University of Technology in Brisbane, Australia, said the agency urgently needs to provide clear preventive measures on airborne transmissi­on. Specifical­ly, it suggests the WHO promotes efficient ventilatio­n and discourage­s overcrowdi­ng in public spaces.

It also calls on the WHO to recommend that people avoid overcrowdi­ng, particular­ly on public transporta­tion and in other confined spaces.

“We are concerned that the lack of recognitio­n of the risk of airborne transmissi­on of COVID19 and the lack of clear recommenda­tions on the control measures against the airborne virus will have significan­t consequenc­es,” the scientists wrote. “People may think they are fully protected by adhering to the current recommenda­tions but, in fact, additional airborne interventi­ons are needed.”

The WHO has been criticized for lagging behind the scientific community in its response to the coronaviru­s pandemic. In two alarming instances, the agency declined to recommend maskwearin­g for the general public during the early stages of the pandemic and asserted that transmissi­on of the virus by asymptomat­ic individual­s is “very rare.” It walked back both claims following pushback from researcher­s.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States