Smallest rise yet in premiums for state ACA plans
Premiums for health plans sold through Covered California, the state’s Affordable Care Act insurance exchange, will rise an average of 0.6% next year — the smallest hike since it started providing coverage in 2014, the agency announced Tuesday.
The modest increase follows an average statewide increase of 0.8% on coverage that started in January, which was the previous record low.
The rate changes will vary across regions, ranging from an average increase of 5.6% in Santa Clara County to reductions of 2.1% in southwestern Los Angeles County and 2.6% in Mono, Inyo and Imperial counties.
Before the announcement, some industry observers had called for rate cuts, given the windfall health plans have reaped so far this year from lower spending on care. The COVID19 pandemic
shut down elective surgeries in the spring and has continued to sharply reduce patient visits to doctors, ERs and outpatient clinics.
But Peter Lee, Covered California’s executive director, told California Healthline that lower spending by insurers due to the pandemic had “very, very little” impact on 2021 premiums.
Covered California’s insurance carriers “are seeing their health care costs rebound and are projecting that for the balance of the year they will catch up on the health expenses they thought they were going to spend for 2020,” Lee said. Health plans in the exchange projected increases in nonCOVID medical costs of 4% to 8% next year and did not think they needed to budget extra for the pandemic, he said.
The rate increase was modest mainly because of a surge of new, “healthier” enrollees both during the regular enrollment period for 2020 coverage and the current “special” enrollment period — recently extended to Aug. 31 — for people whose coverage has been affected by the pandemic, Lee said. Covered California said an analysis of the medical risk and demographics of these newcomers showed “they are healthier on average than the equivalent cohorts from 2019.”
But Kaiser Permanente said in a regulatory filing that it saw no change in the overall health of enrollees, and Anthem Blue Cross expected a less healthy patient mix, pushing costs up about 2.2%,
Covered California said that other factors keeping the average rate hike low include the repeal of a federal tax on health plans, which reduced 2021 premiums by an average of 1.7%, and a cut next year in the participation fee that health plans pay Covered California, from 3.5% of premiums to 3.25%.
The exchange provides coverage for about 1.5 million Californians who buy their own insurance. About 90% of them receive financial assistance from the federal or state government, or both, to help them pay for their premiums. Another 800,000 Californians buy coverage in the open market, where financial assistance is not available. About 600,000 of that group are in plans that mirror those available on the exchange and will see the same rate increase.
Glenn Melnick, professor of public finance at the University of Southern California’s Sol Price School of Public Policy, differed with Lee’s view of the spending trend, saying health plans will likely continue to benefit from depressed patient volume next year, which will more than offset their assumed 4% to 8% increase in nonCOVID costs.
ER visits are lagging prepandemic levels by about 20% and outpatient volume is about 5% to 10% down, Melnick said. “I don’t see those people coming back unless there’s a vaccine — and when there’s a spike, more people will stay home.”
Michael Johnson, a health insurance industry observer and critic who worked as an executive at Blue Shield of California from 2003 to 2015, said next year’s premiums should be lower. “Preliminary indications are that rates for 2020 are way too high, so for 2021 they should be going down, not up,” he said.
The average statewide increase among Covered California carriers is smaller than proposals in many other states.
A Kaiser Family Foundation analysis last month of proposed 2021 rates in the exchanges of 10 states and the District of Columbia showed a median increase of 2.4%, with changes ranging from a hike of 31.8% by a health plan in New Mexico to a cut of 12% by one in Maryland.
This year’s rate announcements come as the Affordable Care Act remains under threat from a federal lawsuit by Republican officials in 18 states, joined by the Trump administration, who want to repeal it. If they prevail, more than 20 million people could lose their health coverage, and popular consumer protections afforded by the ACA, including the ban on health plan discrimination against people with preexisting medical conditions, could be eliminated.
The Supreme Court plans to hear the case in the fall.
All 11 insurance companies operating in Covered California this year will remain in 2021, and no new ones will enter the marketplace. But Anthem Blue Cross and Oscar Health Insurance will expand their offerings geographically, the exchange said. Anthem will enter Inyo, Kern, Mono and Orange counties. Oscar will join the competition in San Mateo County. Many of the Covered California health plans are available only in certain regions of the state.
Kaiser Permanente is the largest carrier in the exchange, with about 526,000 enrollees this year, more than onethird of the total. Kaiser is followed by Blue Shield of California, with 392,000, and Health Net, with 232,000.
Kaiser is seeking an average increase of 0.9% in its individual market plans, including those sold in the exchange and outside of it, according to a filing with the state’s Department of Managed Health Care. Last year, Kaiser raised its rates by an average of 0.7%.
Blue Shield of California plans to cut rates by an average of 2.4% statewide, following a hike of 3.6% this year, according to its regulatory filings. One of the main factors in next year’s rate cut, it said, is that it set current premiums with a projection of medical costs that was too high.
Rates differ not only by carrier and by region, but also by the covered person’s age. Premiums also differ by benefit level, from the cheaper “bronze” coverage tier up to the highest, known as “platinum.” The lower the premium, the higher the deductibles and coinsurance payments for care.
The individual deductible for the bronze tier in 2021 is set at $6,300, unchanged from this year. For the silver tier, the secondcheapest level of coverage, the full individual deductible in 2021 will be $4,000, also unchanged from this year. But many silver enrollees are in plans that offer financial aid to reduce their share of medical costs, and that can push the 2021 silver deductible as low as $75.
Moreover, numerous medical services are not subject to the deductible in silver plans, including primary care and specialist visits, lab tests, Xrays and other imaging. In bronze plans, the first three primary care visits are not subject to the deductible.
Covered California said that, on average, exchange enrollees who plan to renew for 2021 can save 7.3% on premiums by switching to the least expensive plan in the same tier of coverage.
The 2021 rates are subject to final review by the Department of Managed Health Care and the Department of Insurance, but significant changes are unlikely. The enrollment period for 2021 coverage starts Nov. 1 and runs through Jan. 31.
Bernard Wolfson is a columnist and senior correspondent for California Healthline, an editorially independent service of the California Health Care Foundation. California Healthline is produced by Kaiser Health News, which is not affiliated with Kaiser Permanente. Email: bwolfson@kff.org