San Francisco Chronicle

In need of oversight

- Betsy Cawn, Upper Lake

Regarding “Is fire risk too great to allow developmen­t?” (Front Page, March 11) and “Build in cities, not the hinterland­s” (Editorial, March 11): Two articles (one on the front page, the other in the editorial section) characteri­ze the proposed developmen­t in Lake County as a “housing” project. It is not; the addition of highdollar domiciles to the landscape alteration­s surroundin­g a collection of extremely highdollar resorts, hotels, golf courses and lifestyle amenities is not a “muchneeded housing” boon for our county. The bones of contention over defensibil­ity of the fireprone environmen­t there gloss over the difficulti­es of sustaining finite volumes of water supplies and delivery of those supplies to firefighti­ng forces at the site on a narrow, twolane “highway” with wellknown traffic-flow impediment­s, many miles from Cal Fire and local fire protection facilities. The proposed project claims to include a fullblown fire protection service on site, but also seeks to develop water supplies that may impact the central commercial zone called Middletown.

Water rights that were adjudicate­d up through the state’s Supreme Court, protecting the preexistin­g residentia­l and business operations, may be the decisive factor in the scale and type of constructi­on that is ultimately allowed. We appreciate the oversight of California Attorney General Xavier Becerra in this matter.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States