Longtime front-office exec Moore fired as Royals’ struggles persist
KANSAS CITY, Mo. — The Kansas City Royals fired longtime executive Dayton Moore on Wednesday, ending the rollercoaster tenure of an influential general manager and president who took the club from perennial 100-game loser to two World Series and the 2015 championship before its quick return to mediocrity.
Royals owner John Sherman, who retained Moore after acquiring the club from David Glass in 2019, announced the move during a news conference at which Moore spoke briefly before quietly leaving.
“I think the objective is clear: It's to compete again for championships, and we have to make sure we're progressing toward that goal,” said Sherman, whose club was 30 games below .500 going into Wednesday's game.
“In 2022, we regressed,” Sherman said, “and that happens. It happens to great teams. But as I started talking to Dayton and others, I felt like we needed more change than was talked about, and that was a big reason to make this one.”
Sherman tried a mild shakeup to the front office last offseason, elevating Moore from general manager to president of baseball operations and giving J.J. Picollo the GM title. The awkward splitting of jobs did not work, and Picollo now will handle all aspects of baseball operations.
“This job, from my experience, is all about evaluating, selecting and developing talent, and getting the most out of that talent,” Sherman said. “He's very excited about this opportunity, and certainly it's bittersweet for him having spent so much time under Dayton. But this is what his career has prepared him to do.”
Moore was hired in 2006 and tasked with rebuilding an organization that had not reached the playoffs in more than two decades. He quickly followed the blueprint that he learned from longtime Braves executive John Schuerholz, investing in Latin America and the minorleague system before spending on proven major-league players.
It took most of another decade for the plan to work, but the Royals began to see progress with a winning record in 2013, when a wave of young players began to reach the majors. The breakthrough came the following year, when a team built around Eric Hosmer and Mike Moustakas won the first of two consecutive AL pennants.
The Royals lost their first trip to the World Series to the Giants in a dramatic seven-game series, but they finished the job the following year, beating the Mets in five for their first Series championship since 1985.
Moore knew it would be impossible for the small-market organization to keep that team together as Hosmer and others hit free agency. So after a middling season in 2016, the Royals began again with a nearly topto-bottom rebuild — one that has been hamstrung by poor drafts, lousy player development and the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on baseball.
“There is a gap right now between where we are and where we expected,” Sherman said. “I felt like in 2021, we did make progress, and in 2022, that's not how I feel.”
The organization Picollo is tasked with taking to the next level is better off than what Moore inherited: Infielder Bobby Witt Jr. is among the leading contenders for AL Rookie of the Year, and rookies such as Vinnie Pasquantino and MJ Melendez give Kansas City a core reminiscent of the group Hosmer and Moustakas once led.
Yet there are organizational problems for Picollo to address.
The Royals have struggled to develop pitching — their staff has the fourth-worst ERA in baseball and the worst WHIP, which led to the firing of pitching coordinator Jason Simontacchi this season.
They have struggled to identify impact talent in the draft, whiffing on first-round picks.
And they have struggled to keep pace with the changing times, preferring old-school, anecdotal scouting methods to new-school analytics and datadriven decision-making that has leveled the playing field with big-market ballclubs.
“Dayton always talks about what a championship team looks like. That's a great conversation,” Sherman said, “but I'd like to know what a wildcard team looks like first. Because Kansas City fans know, if you can get a wild-card slot and get into the dance, anything can happen.”