South Florida Sun-Sentinel Palm Beach (Sunday)
Caught in corporate controversy
A look at companies embroiled in recent political debates
NEW YORK — Nike’s “Just Do It” campaign featuring Colin Kaepernick is a rare example of a brand jumping into a divisive issue uninvited. Still, like it or not, American companies are increasingly being pulled into the country’s political and cultural wars.
Here’s a look at other companies that recently have courted controversy or been caught in political turbulence.
Patagonia:
The outdoor retailer dived head-first into politics last year with a campaign against President Donald Trump’s move to dramatically shrink two Utah national monuments. On the day of Trump’s announcement, the California-based outdoor clothing company replaced its usual home page with a black screen and stark message: “The President Stole Your Land.” The company also filed a lawsuit to block the planned reduction to Utah’s Bears Ears National Monument. Other outdoor retailers including The North Face, Keen, Black Diamond and REI also protested Trump’s plan on social media, but Patagonia was the only one to file a lawsuit.
Delta Airlines
was only one of many companies that made policy changes in the wake of the Feb. 14 school shooting in Parkland, Fla., but it faced the most notable retaliation. The airliner stopped offering fare discounts to NRA members after the massacre, a decision the company said was an effort to remove itself from the debate, not take sides. Still, Georgia state lawmakers swiftly punished the Atlanta-based company by killing a pro- posed tax break on fuel. Delta stood by its decision, and in March, the company donated three round-trip charter flights that allowed hundreds of Parkland’s Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School students to participate in protests against gun violence in Washington.
Citigroup
became the first bank to announce policy changes after the Parkland massacre, announcing it would require its clients and business customers not to sell a gun to anyone who hasn’t passed a background check or anyone under the age of 21. The bank also will not allow its customers to sell what are known as bump stocks and high-capacity magazines. Other financial industry players followed with their own measures, including Bank of America, which cut off financing to companies that make AR-style rifles. The Republican chairman of the Senate Banking Committee, Sen. Mike Crapo, sent letters of protest accusing both banks of trying to usurp the role of policymakers. Retailers including Walmart Inc., Dicks Sporting Goods, Kroger Co. and L.L. Bean also responded to the shooting with measures tightening their restrictions on gun sales.
Starbucks
faced a backlash three years ago when it encouraged employees to write “Race Together” on its coffee cups to encourage a national conversation on race amid protests over police killings of black men. The initiative was in line with the Seattle-based company’s efforts to project a progressive image, but social media users ridiculed it as a stunt to drive up sales. Then- CEO Howard Schultz defended the cam- paign as part of a broader push that included investing in underserved communities and striving to diversify its workforce.
Merck
CEO Kenneth Frazier, at the time one of only four African-Americans leading a Fortune 500 company, was the first to resign from Trump’s business councils last summer over the president’s remarks on the white nationalist protests in Charlottesville, Va. The president lashed out immediately, criticizing Frazier on Twitter over drug pricing. Some business leaders quickly followed Frazier’s lead, including the CEOs of Under Armour and Intel. Others, including the heads Walmart and Johnson & Johnson, publicly condemned Trump’s remarks but initially resisted pressure to leave the councils. Within days, however, the ballooning uproar pushed the companies to shift course, and the panel fell apart.
Uber:
Shortly after Trump took office in 2017, thenUber CEO Travis Kalanick quit Trump’s council of business leaders after an outcry from Uber customers and employees who were upset about the administration’s travel ban on people from seven majorityMuslim countries. Other Silicon Valley giants also took a strong stand against the ban in ads, including Google, Apple, Microsoft, eBay, Netflix, Facebook and Twitter. Through ads, public statements and court filings, CEOs spoke out about the reliance of high tech on immigrants. Tech companies also spoke out forcefully against the Trump administration’s decision to rescind the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, which al- lows some people brought to the company illegally as children to stay.
Bank of America:
As the largest North Carolinabased company, Bank of America found itself squarely in the middle of the heated debate over a state law that required transgender people to use restrooms corresponding to the sex on their birth certificates in many public buildings. The bill prompted businesses, sporting events, conventions and entertainers pull out of the state in a yearlong economic backlash. Bank of America was among the leading critics of the bill, saying it was bad for business. The bank then supported a compromise bill last year that removed the requirement but also made clear that only state legislators — not local government or school officials — can make rules for public restrooms from now on.
Nordstrom
incurred Trump’s wrath last year when it stopped selling daughter Ivanka’s clothing and accessories. The move came amid a social media campaign called “Grab Your Wallet,” urging a boycott of stores that stocked Ivanka Trump or Donald Trump products. But Nordstrom said its decision was based on the sales performance of the first daughter’s brand.
Harley-Davidson:
Several companies have been pulled into controversy by Trump himself. Most recently, Harley-Davidson drew the president’s ire when it announced plans to move production of motorcycles sold in Europe to facilities outside the U.S, citing tariffs imposed by the European Union to retaliate for tariffs Trump imposed on a host of EU products. Trump said last month that his administration is courting other motorcycle companies that want to move to the U.S.