South Florida Sun-Sentinel (Sunday)

Name prompts queries if it’s ‘real’

- Amy Dickinson Readers can send email to askamy@ amydickins­on.com or mail letters to “Ask Amy” P.O. Box 194, Freeville, NY, 13068.

Dear Amy: I am a foreign-born U.S. citizen from Hong Kong, a formerly British colony for more than a century. I have lived in the U.S. for 40 years. It is common for people in Hong Kong to use a western name and our Chinese name together.

Occasional­ly strangers in the U.S. ask me if “Lily Wong” is my “real” name.

It is on my British passport, U.S. passport, global entry card, driver’s license, property deed, and so on.

I feel discrimina­ted against because I have an Asian face and an Asian accent and they want to point out the obvious — that I was not born here.

I think corporatio­ns should include sensitivit­y training to educate employees not to ask if someone’s name is “real” — to point out the obvious. — Upset Citizen

Dear Upset: People ask all sorts of insensitiv­e questions, not always because they are trying to discrimina­te, upset you or point out your “otherness,” but because they are curious — or clueless — or a combinatio­n of both.

I agree that corporatio­ns should include sensitivit­y training, so that people are sensitized to realize that what sounds like a benign question: “Is that your real name?” or, “Where are you from?” has the opposite effect from what they might intend.

Asking a person from Cleveland who has an American accent, “Where are you from” is perceived differentl­y than when it is asked of you. An American-born or “American-looking” (whatever that is) person might see this as a social ice-breaker. You see it as an indication that the person asking doesn’t think you belong here.

You might be wrong about that, or overly sensitive. But let’s just stipulate that asking a fellow human being, “What are you?” is offensive.

One way to respond to a question you don’t feel like answering is to turn it back on the questioner. If you are asked, “Is that your real name?” You could answer, “Why are you asking?” Depending on the response, you could simply answer, “Yes, it is my real name.”

I hope you will see the movie “Crazy Rich Asians.” This runaway American hit with an all-Asian cast explores, exploits and explodes these stereotype­s.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States