South Florida Sun-Sentinel (Sunday)

‘Person. Woman. Man. Camera. TV.’

Trump tries to turn cognitive test into a campaign issue

- By Jonathan Lemire, Seth Borenstein and Will Weissert

WASHINGTON — It doesn’t quite have the ring of “Morning in America” and “I Like Ike.”

But “Person. Woman. Man. Camera. TV.” is getting an unlikely moment in the spotlight as President Donald Trump has taken a detour into the politics of dementia ahead of November’s election.

Trump, 74, attempted to demonstrat­e his mental fitness by reciting five words — in order, importantl­y — over and over in a television interview broadcast Wednesday night. The president said that collection of nouns, or ones like them, was part of a cognitive test he had aced while declaring his likely Democratic opponent, 77-yearold Joe Biden, could not do the same.

The Trump campaign has long tried to paint Biden as having lost some of his mental sharpness. But the gambit has yet to prove successful in denting the former vice president’s standing in the race. That leaves Trump trying to escalate the attacks while defending his own ability to handle the mental rigors of the job.

“The first questions are very easy,” Trump told Fox News. “The last questions are much more difficult. Like a memory question. It’s, like, you’ll go: Person. Woman. Man. Camera. TV. So they say, ‘Could you repeat that?’ So I said, ‘Yeah. It’s: Person. Woman. Man. Camera. TV.’ ”

He then recalled that, at the end of the test, the doctor asked him to recite it again.

“And you go: ‘Person. Woman. Man. Camera. TV.’ If you get it in order, you get

President Trump, whose father had Alzheimer’s, has tried to paint Joe Biden as having lost some of his mental sharpness.

extra points,” Trump said. “They said nobody gets it in order. It’s actually not that easy, but for me, it was easy.”

Trump boasted that he dazzled the doctors because he has “a good memory, because I’m cognitivel­y there” and delivered an unsubtle accusation about Biden. “Now Joe should take that test because something’s going on,” Trump said. “And, I say this with respect. I mean — going to probably happen to all of us, right? You know? It’s going to happen.”

The subject of smarts — especially his own — has long fascinated the president.

Trump has been known to declare that he is “a very stable genius“and that “I have the best words” while noting he attended the prestigiou­s Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvan­ia. And about a month ago, he began telling aides that a cognitive test he took as part of his physical in 2018 could be something

he could weaponize against Biden.

The president has been known to recite five words to aides in the West Wing or on Air Force One — he’d tweak the list to make it appropriat­e for the setting — while claiming that Biden could not do the same.

But some of Trump’s descriptio­ns about the test and what it means don’t quite fit with what experts describe about the most common of cognitive tests given to older people. There is no bonus and it’s meant to be easy, said Dr. James Galvin, a University of Miami professor of neurology who runs a dementia center.

Galvin said what Trump described sounds like the Montreal Cognitive Assessment, often called MoCa. It takes about 10 minutes and the top score is 30, said Galvin, who has administra­ted thousands of the tests.

The MoCa “is a screening test,” Galvin said. “It’s

a diagnostic test. And more importantl­y, it’s not an IQ test. It doesn’t tell how smart someone is. It’s designed to be a relatively easy test because what you want to do is pick up people who have problems or possible problems.”

The last questions are not the hardest for most people, and they are usually naming the day of the week, date, month, year and where the person being tested is, Galvin said. The test does not get harder as it goes along but measures different parts of cognition, like memory, attention, spatial awareness and language. Additional­ly, the words the president cited would not be grouped together because they are all in some way related to one another, he said.

And the real concern would be if a subject did not do well on the test.

“I think he’s thinking of it like some sort of IQ test or SAT test, something along those lines. But it’s not

anything like that. It’s just basic,” said Dr. Raymond Turner, professor of neurology and director of Georgetown University’s Memory Disorders Program. “It’s kind of a low bar to jump over. It’s not necessaril­y something to brag about unless you are worried about decline or something.”

Trump, whose father had Alzheimer’s disease, has said his former personal physician Dr. Ronny Jackson accompanie­d him to the test in 2018. Jackson, who is running for a Texas seat in the U.S. House, did not respond to an interview request.

Questions about presidenti­al health, mental or otherwise, tend to be closely guarded and rarely made the subject of national cable interviews. They have been part of the national dialogue before, including President Ronald Reagan’s mental health during his second term, though the health woes of Presinot dents Franklin Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson were largely kept from the public.

But the Trump campaign has leaned in on the issue, despite the boomerang effect of highlighti­ng the president’s own verbal missteps, as a means of suggesting that Biden’s blunders meant he was not up to the job.

“Any honest voter juxtaposin­g President Trump and Joe Biden can see the stark difference in mental acuity and wit,” said Trump spokespers­on Ken Farnaso, before adding “it’s their track records and not their ages that are in question here, and it’s clear that President Trump’s America First agenda is a winning platform.”

When Biden was asked about cognitive testing last month, he responded, “I’ve been tested and I’m constantly tested,” before adding, “I can hardly wait to compare my cognitive capability to the cognitive capability of the man I’m running against.”

The Biden campaign clarified that its candidate was referring to the rigor of the presidenti­al campaign — not that he had undergone specific cognitive testing. And a campaign spokespers­on wasted no time rebutting Trump’s claim Thursday.

“Donald Trump is spectacula­rly failing every conceivabl­e strategic test by ramping up mentions of this subject at all,” said spokespers­on Andrew Bates. “Joe Biden sounded the alarm about the outbreak early, whereas Donald Trump is still promising us the virus will magically ‘disappear.’ Joe Biden has highlighte­d the advice of medical experts throughout the pandemic, but Donald Trump publicly encouraged COVID-19 victims to inject themselves with disinfecta­nt.

“And,” Bates continued, “if that’s not enough for you, ‘Person. Woman. Man. Camera. TV.’ ”

 ?? EVAN VUCCI/AP ??
EVAN VUCCI/AP

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States