What the feds have on ‘Diddy’ and what they need to prove
Four women have accused hip-hop mogul of sexual abuse.
LOS ANGELES — Over the last few months, a legendary name in the music world has faced a series of shocking allegations of sexual abuse.
In civil lawsuits, four women have accused Sean “Diddy” Combs of rape, assault and a litany of other abuses, dating back three decades. One of the allegations involved a minor. The claims sent shock waves through the music industry and put Combs’ entertainment empire in jeopardy.
Now, the hip-hop mogul’s legal troubles have worsened considerably.
Law enforcement sources told The Times that Combs is the subject of a sweeping inquiry into sex trafficking allegations that resulted in a federal raid Monday at his estates in Los Angeles and Miami.
Authorities have declined to comment on the case, and Combs has not been charged with any crimes. But the scene of dozens of Department of
Homeland Security agents — guns drawn — searching Combs’ properties underscored the seriousness of the investigation.
Sources with knowledge of the case, who spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to speak publicly, said federal authorities have interviewed at least three women, but it’s unclear whether any are included in those who have filed suit.
Legal experts say it could take time to build a criminal case against Combs but note that the civil suits could offer investigators a road map.
Dmitry Gorin, a former L.A.
County sex crimes prosecutor who is now in private practice, said the allegations in the lawsuits would likely have been enough for a judge to grant search warrants for Combs’ homes.
Investigators likely would seek authorization to “search for videos or photographs on any devices connected to the target ... anywhere where digital images can be found in connection to sexual conduct that would have been recorded,” Gorin said.
Gorin and other legal experts said investigators could be focused, in part, on the sexual assault allegations involving a minor. If a minor is moved across state lines for the purpose of sex, “that is enough for at least an argument ... of sex trafficking because somebody underage cannot consent,” Gorin said.
“Sex trafficking for adults usually involves some sort of coercion or other restraints,” he said, and can be tougher
to prove. Prosecutors would need to show you “encouraged somebody to engage in sexual activity for money or some other inducement.”
Coercion, he added, is not limited to threats of violence. It could involve being held against one’s will or someone simply saying, “I don’t want to participate in group sex, and now I’m being forced to.”
Meghan Blanco, a defense attorney who has handled sexual trafficking cases, said they can be “incredibly difficult cases to prove.”
“They have [in the Combs case] convinced one or more federal magistrates they had enough probable cause for one or more search warrants,” Blanco said. “Given the scope of the investigation, it seems they are further along than most investigations.”
Combs’ legal troubles have been building for months.
His former girlfriend, Casandra Ventura, the singer known as Cassie, accused him of rape and repeated physical assaults and said he forced her to have sex with male prostitutes in front of him. Joi Dickerson-neal accused Combs in a suit of drugging and raping her in 1991, recording the attack and then distributing the footage without her consent.
Liza Gardner filed a third suit in which she claimed Combs and R&B singer Aaron Hall sexually assaulted her. Hall could not be reached for comment.
Another lawsuit alleges Combs and former Bad Boy label president Harve Pierre gang-raped and sex-trafficked a 17-year-old girl. Pierre said in a statement the allegations were “disgusting,” “false” and a “desperate attempt for financial gain.”
After the filing of the fourth suit, Combs wrote on Instagram: “Enough is enough. For the last couple of weeks, I have sat silently and watched people try to assassinate my character, destroy my reputation and my legacy. Sickening allegations have been made against me by individuals looking for a quick payday. Let me be absolutely clear: I did not do any of the awful things being alleged. I will fight for my name, my family and for the truth.”
Last month, producer Rodney “Lil Rod” Jones filed a federal lawsuit against Combs accusing the embattled media mogul of sexually harassing and threatening him for more than a year.
Blanco said prosecutors “are going to look carefully for corroboration — the numbers of people accusing the person of similar acts.” Beyond that, they will be looking for videos, recordings and cellphone records that place people in the same locations or text messages or other discussions at the time of the alleged acts.
She said prosecutors are trying to build a record of incidents that happened some time ago.
On Monday, Douglas Wigdor,
a lawyer for Ventura and another, unnamed plaintiff, said in response to reports of the search warrant issued against Combs: “We will always support law enforcement when it seeks to prosecute those that have violated the law. Hopefully, this is the beginning of a process that will hold Mr. Combs responsible for his depraved conduct.”
The searches Monday in L.A. and Miami sparked worldwide attention.
His 17,000-square-foot Holmby Hills mansion, where Combs debuted his last album a year ago, was flooded with Homeland Security agents who gathered evidence on behalf of an investigation being run by the Southern District of New York, according to law enforcement officials familiar with the inquiry.
Two of Combs’ sons were briefly detained at the Holmby Hills property as agents searched the mansion in footage captured by FOX11 Los Angeles.
Both Blanco and Gorin said prosecutors will have to examine the alleged victims’ motives for coming forward and whether they are motivated by financial gain. They are sure to look for inconsistencies in any allegations, they said.
Any defense, Blanco added, will question why the accusers are only now coming forward and whether they have an incentive beyond justice.
“It comes down to credibility,” she said.