Sun Sentinel Palm Beach Edition

I’ve carried a firearm for years. Repeal the Second Amendment.

- By Rich Logis Rich Logis, of Delray Beach, has held a Florida concealed carry permit for five years and is a former right-wing commentato­r.

I have carried a concealed firearm for years, everywhere I go, except where prohibited by law or a business’s policy.

Hanging in my office is a 100% American-made Gadsden flag.

For years, I voted for Republican­s, including twice for former president Donald Trump, and once for Gov. Ron DeSantis (in 2018).

And I’m here to tell you that the Second Amendment needs to be repealed and replaced, because it has nearly zero modern-day applicabil­ity.

Many of the Floridians I once congregate­d with truly believe there is an ongoing “leftist” conspiracy to confiscate their firearms. “Molon Labé!,” we pronounced! The inevitable permitless carry that will soon become Florida law will be enacted to propitiate these same Republican­s, who think God granted an absolute right to carry a firearm, but overlooked slavery and gender discrimina­tion, among other actual tyrannies. To quote the late George Carlin: Doesn’t sound like divine planning to me.

Permitless carry makes communitie­s more dangerous. Period. The Florida Republican Party, and DeSantis, know this. Why else has the state GOP consistent­ly criminaliz­ed civilian carrying of firearms during any legislativ­e, or committee, meeting and banned guns from election victory parties?

The Second Amendment was a compromise of James Madison’s. Likely its most important goal was to prevent the federal government from starting a profession­al army. This was relevant to our Southern states, where slave population­s were disproport­ionately higher than other states’. Militias controlled states’ security, especially because of concerns over slave revolts. There was a fear amongst some of the Founders that the Haitian Revolution — the first-known successful uprising in the Americas of slaves against their masters — would inspire U.S. slaves to revolt. The Second Amendment assuaged these worries. Side note: Blacks were overwhelmi­ngly prohibited from keeping and bearing arms.

An individual right to firearm ownership was affirmed by the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2008 District of Columbia v.

Heller decision. And last year, the Court struck down a New York state requiremen­t that people show “good cause” to receive a gun permit. I agreed with the court’s decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Associatio­n v. Bruen, but Bruen’s history-based tests are resulting in unimaginab­le regression­s of commonsens­e public safety laws, as well as rollbacks of statutes protecting victims of domestic violence.

I carry a firearm for protection. Although data on defensive gun use is unclear — no thanks to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention under the Biden administra­tion, which bowed to pressure from gun control advocates and removed studies on defensive gun use from its website — it’s impossible that it doesn’t happen on a daily basis, given that Americans own 400 million (or more) guns, and several trillion rounds of ammunition. Repealing the Second is, perhaps, unrealisti­cally ambitious. The more repeal is mainstream­ed, however, the more meaningful gun safety legislatio­n will come to fruition.

Here are legislativ­e solutions that are supported by the vast majority of Floridians (and Americans), including gun owners:

„ ■ Age 21 to own any gun, with some exceptions for law enforcemen­t, military service and bequeathin­g; inheritanc­e exemptions will only cover certain types of low-powered guns.

„ ■ National firearm registry, to assist law enforcemen­t in criminal investigat­ions; included here are inheritors.

„ ■ Codify mandatory record-keeping and reporting of prohibited persons, and the mentally ill, by all states, to federal databases.

„ ■ Background checks for all firearm sales performed by federally licensed dealers.

„ ■ Background checks on all ammunition.

„ ■ Annual Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) background checks for all firearm owners (including inheritors), with reasonably allowed grace periods for failure to comply; dealers could conduct these checks;

„ ■ Reclassifi­cation of any firearm that holds 10 or more rounds in a magazine; any firearm holding 10 or more will be levied an excise tax (a tax at the time of manufactur­e, not time of sale); funds collected from excise taxes to be used for a variety of initiative­s, such as gun violence studies and research and federally administer­ed liability insurance.

„ ■ Enshrineme­nt of compulsory concealed carry permitting (but not “good cause”); prohibitio­n of open carry.

„ ■ A federal buyback program, offering to buy firearms for the same price as purchased.

„ ■ Red flag laws — irrefutabl­e lifesavers — in all states.

None of these are infringeme­nts.

In 1789, Thomas Jefferson wrote to Madison that the “earth belongs always to the living generation.”

The Second Amendment belongs to an epoch of America that has not existed for centuries. The living must demand its repeal.

 ?? ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States