Texarkana Gazette

A code of conduct for the Supreme Court?

- St. Louis Post-Dispatch

Supreme Court justices adamantly declare they are above the grubby machinatio­ns of partisan politics. But that narrative is contradict­ed by events like last week’s speech by Justice Neil Gorsuch to a closeddoor gathering of the conservati­ve Federalist Society that also included such Republican luminaries as former Vice President Mike Pence and Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis.

Justice Clarence Thomas, meanwhile, refuses to recuse himself from cases in which his conservati­ve-activist wife is actively engaged.

Lofty declaratio­ns aside, some justices aren’t even going through the motions anymore of staying above the partisan fray. That’s not good for a nation that increasing­ly views the high court as just another combatant in the culture wars. Calls for a formalized code of conduct could help.

Claims to nonpartisa­nship are difficult to believe when the conservati­ve block repeatedly renders decisions that appear to be less about legal conclusion­s than political ones. The latest example was this week’s 5-4 decision allowing Alabama to keep a congressio­nal map that creates just one district (of seven total) favorable to a Black candidate, even though Black citizens make up more than a quarter of the state’s population. The map is clearly designed to undermine not only Black representa­tion, but Democratic power.

You may recall Justice Amy Coney Barrett’s speech last September waxing on about the court’s political independen­ce — a claim she made, straight-faced, as a guest of Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, at an academic center that bears his name, less than a year after McConnell’s controvers­ial rush-job to seat her before a Democratic president could take office.

A group of legal scholars last week implored Chief Justice John Roberts to adopt of code of conduct for the justices. That would seem to be undebatabl­y needed if only to restore flagging public trust in the court.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States