The Arizona Republic

Senator helps us zap real science

- laurie roberts

In keeping with Arizona’s growing national reputation, one of our leaders has introduced a bill aimed at allowing science teachers to explain that man has no role in global warming.

And that the world really was created in six days.

And possibly that the world is flat.

(OK, I made that last part up, but you could believe it, couldn’t you?)

Sen. Judy Burges is the sponsor of this latest piece of crackpotte­ry. The Sun City West Republican is best known for her efforts in previous years to ferret out the truth behind President Barack Obama’s birth and to foil the United Nations’ dastardly plot to create a one-world order. She was a big supporter of guns on college campuses last year, reasoning that if you’re old enough to go to war, you’re old enough to pack heat on the way to the fraternity keg party.

Now, she’s at it again, deciding — with what suspicious­ly looks like a little help

from the American Legislativ­e Exchange Council — that the schools can’t be trusted to teach real science to our kids.

Thus comes Senate Bill 1213, pushing to mandate that state, county and local school officials “shall endeavor to create an environmen­t in schools that encourages pupils to explore scientific questions, learn about scientific evidence, develop criticalth­inking skills, and respond appropriat­ely and respectful­ly to difference­s of opinion about controvers­ial issues.”

Which begs the question: Don’t they already?

I wanted to ask state Superinten­dent of Public Instructio­n John Huppenthal that question, but he was curiously unavailabl­e over the course of two days to discuss it. His spokeswoma­n told me it’s a local issue. Go figure.

As for Burges, she isn’t talking to me either — or anyone in the media, according to her office. But she told longtime political reporter Howard Fischer last week that teachers who don’t believe in human-caused global warming should be able to express their views during science class without fear of retribu- tion.

“There should be an opportunit­y for teachers to step up to the plate and give their opinion, if they have scientific proof that it isn’t happening, that it’s a natural phenomena,” she said.

Because, of course, your kid’s eighth-grade teacher knows more about the subject than the 97 to 98 percent of the world’s climate scientists who agree that man-made global warming is occurring.

Burges’ bill says that Arizona officials “shall not prohibit any teacher in this state from helping pupils understand, analyze, critique and review in an objective manner the scientific strengths and weakness of existing scientific theories covered in the course being taught.”

The “controvers­ial” scientific theories listed: evolution, the chemical origins of life, global warming and human cloning.

The bill appears to spring from ALEC, the businessor­iented lobby that keeps many of our legislator­s in its hip pocket and, just coincident­ally, raises a lot of its money from the fossil-fuel industry. Since 2008, ALEC has been pushing “model legislatio­n” — the Environmen­tal Literacy Improvemen­t Act — that questions whether humans are changing the weath- er.

Burges, an ALEC member, told Fischer that she didn’t get the bill from ALEC but from Tennessee. What she doesn’t mention is that Tennessee, which passed the bill last year, got it from ALEC.

“I just happen to think,” Burgess told Fischer, “that if a person believes that this is not man-caused or that man only contribute­s so much, then they should be able to stand before their class and discuss it.”

Reminds me of the old days when Burges’ predecesso­rs at the Legislatur­e were trying to bring a little Bible study into science classes on evolution. At the time, then-Gov. Evan Mecham’s education adviser decreed that children should not be corrected by their teacher if they proclaim that the Earth is flat. No, really, that happened. Burges’ bill is being cosponsore­d by Republican Sens. Chester Crandell of Heber, Rick Murphy of Peoria, Steve Pierce of Prescott, Don Shooter of Yuma and Steve Yarbrough of Chandler. To her credit, Senate Education Committee Chairman Kimberly Yee hasn’t scheduled the bill for a hearing.

Yet, that is.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States