The Arizona Republic

Is Sinema’s Canyon bill radioactiv­e for McSally?

- EJ Montini Columnist

Let us begin the year with good news.

Great news, even.

Late in December, Sen. Kyrsten Sinema introduced legislatio­n that would preserve and protect the Grand Canyon in a manner that would last essentiall­y, forever, saying, “Arizona’s economy depends on protecting the Grand Canyon and ensuring it remains a safe and stunning part of our outdoor heritage for generation­s to come.” Truth.

There are many different and conflictin­g points of view within our desert paradise, but safeguardi­ng the Canyon, making sure that its unsurpasse­d beauty and majesty is open and available for our children and all of those who follow is something upon which we can all agree ... with the possible exception of Sen. Martha McSally.

Sinema’s bill puts her in a pickle. Last year, the House passed a similar bill. It was introduced by Arizona Democratic Rep. Raul Grijalva. The legislatio­n is meant to permanentl­y ban uranium mining near the canyon, something that environmen­talists, native tribes and just about anyone with common sense believes to be a good idea.

The mining industry disagrees, however, and has been lobbying President Donald Trump to give them the go ahead to explore the canyon area.

When reporters asked McSally about this after the House bill was passed she avoided the question.

I’d guess that McSally, like most of us, is awed by the Grand Canyon.

Democrats like to point out that she has taken thousands of dollars from mining interests.

But then, politician­s take money from lots of sources, and I don’t particular­ly believe McSally fears the wealthy operators of mines.

She does, however, fear Donald Trump.

I’d guess that McSally fears the president more than she loves the Canyon, or Arizona. This makes her like every other Republican in Congress, operating more out of fear than principle.

That’s a shame.

But it is our reality.

In a release from Sinema’s office, Muriel Uqualla, Havasupai tribal chairwoman, said of Sinema’s bill, “Thirty years ago, when we first began

fighting against the disastrous effects of uranium mining in our homelands, we were alone in this fight. Sen. Sinema’s announceme­nt earlier today sends a strong message that it is important to protect the Grand Canyon. Not only for the Havasupai people, but for all people, for generation­s to come.”

The energy program director for the Grand Canyon Trust, Amber Reimondo, added, “There is no reality in which it is worthwhile to endanger the Grand Canyon, the lives and cultures of Indigenous communitie­s, and millions of people and the economies that support them. For those reasons, the Grand Canyon region is, and forever will be, too precious to mine and today we are grateful to Senator Sinema for her leadership in advancing a permanent mining ban around the Grand Canyon.”

That will only happen if the Senate passes Sinema’s bill.

And that will only happen if Republican­s like McSally do the right thing.

And that will only happen, it seems, if Donald Trump gives her the okay.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States