The Arizona Republic

Start policing the Zone. Enforce the rule of law.

-

against another homeless person does not stigmatize homelessne­ss: it respects the rule of law and the rights of the victim essential to natural order. It recognizes a humanity that inheres in certain population­s too many of us would, evidently, rather ignore. And these prosecutio­ns can result in services being mandated for the homeless perpetrato­r.

But Phoenix is so wrapped in the dogma that pushes the failed policy of “housing first” and appeasemen­t rather than treatment that it leaves the victims with neither justice nor respect. It leaves the homeless abandoned to the vicious cycle of desperatio­n and misery.

The city has been justifying its shameless inaction because of a misreading of a recent 9th Circuit Court of Appeals case. But that case, Robert Martin v. City of Boise, noted, “Nor do we suggest that a jurisdicti­on with insufficie­nt shelter can never criminaliz­e the act of sleeping outside.

“Even where shelter is unavailabl­e, an ordinance prohibitin­g sitting, lying, or sleeping outside at particular times or in particular locations might well be constituti­onally permissibl­e. So, too, might an ordinance barring the obstructio­n of public rights of way or the erection of certain structures.”

Start policing the Zone. Enforce the rule of law.

Start arresting those who break the law. Work with prosecutor­s and courts to screen for services and treatment. Start with a policy not of “housing first” but “protecting victims first.”

That is what a sane and civil community would do — before it spreads, and before more lives are brutalized and lost.

Steve Twist, a former chief assistant attorney general for Arizona, is the founder of the Arizona Voice for Crime Victims. Seth Leibsohn is a radio host at KKNT/960am and a senior fellow of the Claremont Institute, which advocates for limited government. Reach them at steventwis­t@gmail.com and SLeibsohn@salemphx.com.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States