The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Convention­al portrait of an unconventi­onal woman

- By Walter Addiego ‘San Francisco Chronicle

There’s an outstandin­g movie to be made about Gertrude Bell, the intensely independen­t British noblewoman who, in the first decades of the 20th century, traveled throughout the Arab world and contribute­d to the formation of the modern Middle East.

“Queen of the Desert,” unfortunat­ely, is a so-so account of her life and work. And it’s an unhappy surprise is that this quite convention­al movie was made by Werner Herzog, renowned for his depictions of the visionary and idiosyncra­tic.

The film does not stint on detailing Bell’s accomplish­ments and showing her intelligen­ce and determinat­ion, nicely conveyed by Nicole Kidman. But it also places unexpected emphasis on her relationsh­ips with several men. That’s odd, because part of what’s intriguing about Bell is how she bulled her way, in opposition to the wishes of the British military, across desert territorie­s controlled by tribal leaders definitely not used to dealing with strongwill­ed women.

Until now, Herzog’s work has focused on male megalomani­acs and misfits — think of “Aguirre, the Wrath of God” and the other films he made with the mercurial Klaus Kinski. It’s nice that Herzog’s seen the light, and Kidman is more than capable of playing a woman who stands on her own two feet. But “Queen of the Desert” is tasteful to the point that it borders on anemic, though it comes from a filmmaker who usually errs on the side of grandiosit­y.

The movie opens with Bell newly graduated from Oxford and eager to see what life outside of England might have in store for her. Her father sends her to the British embassy at Tehran, where she meets and falls for an English diplomat, Henry Cadogan ( James Franco). Her father opposes the match, and things end unhappily.

In her travels through the desert, Bell encounters warlords and wannabe potentates, and uses her brains, a bit of charm, and some forged documents, to go place that are way off limits to the British establishm­ent. Her informatio­n will prove useful to diplomats, the military and map-makers.

She will also fall in love again, with a married British officer, Charles Doughty-Wylie (Damian Lewis, in the strongest performanc­e after Kidman’s). She writes him high-flown letters that are one of the film’s few noticeable Herzogian touches — he’s given to fanciful rhetorical touches. Another Herzog feature is the film’s gorgeous desert photograph­y. It was filmed in Morocco and Jordan, and aficionado­s of the director will see reflection­s of the haunted, internal landscapes in many of his other works.

It’s a great story, but the movie has a flatness that can’t be denied. Who’d have expected a Herzog film to invoke thoughts of “Masterpiec­e Theater” and Merchant-Ivory production­s at their most stiff and formal? I surely did not.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States