The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Recalling ‘Red Summer’
In 1919, mob burned Ga. church as racial attacks swept U.S.
Around the bend of a rural road in eastern Georgia, towering pines give way to a gnatty glade dotted with aging tombstones and floral bouquets. Secluded and serene, it was the site of a horrific racial trauma. A century ago, a white lynch mob set fire to an African American church on this land just north of Millen, sending hundreds of black parents and their children scrambling out of windows in a frantic effort to escape. The mob, which was out to avenge the killing of two white law enforcement officers, would lynch at least three black males, including a 13-year-old, and leave the Carswell Grove Baptist Church in an ashy heap.
100 years later
It is a little-known piece of history in a community where Southern politeness can mask racial strife. But on the centennial anniversary of the attack in 1919, efforts to acknowledge what happened have created unlikely allies.
Among those who gathered last year in advance of the anniversary to commemorate the church burning and lynchings were black residents whose ancestors were victims of the violence, and members of the Sons of Confederate Veterans, an organization for those whose ancestors fought in the Confederate Army.
The attack in Millen was among the first in a series of clashes across the country in one of the bloodiest — yet largely forgotten — seasons of racial violence in American history. From Elaine, Arkansas, to Chicago to Washington, hundreds of black people died in more than two dozen separate incidents during what is now known as the Red Summer.
Beyond the lynchings, that violent summer became notable for another tactic that white mobs used to strike at the heart of African American communities: attacking black churches just as they were emerging as the center of black life in America.
Carswell Grove was one of more than a dozen churches burned in three Georgia counties that summer, according to various media accounts.
Attacks on black churches continue a century later. Four years ago, Dylann Roof killed nine African American churchgoers who had gathered for Bible study at the Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, South Carolina. This past spring, three African American churches were burned in central Louisiana over 10 days. It is being investigated as a hate crime.
“The black church was the most formidable structure in the community,” said Geoff Ward, associate professor of African and African-American Studies at Washington University in St. Louis who documents historical acts of racial violence. “So physically, the structure, this monument to black achievement, would have been offensive to white supremacist sensibilities. And of course, its loss would be devastating, the memory of the burnings carried by its survivors.
Those memories in Millen have largely faded with time, as have the fortunes of the town and the church. Jenkins County, of which Millen is the seat, was hit hard when its largest employer, a Jockey plant, closed more than a decade ago.
A little fewer than 9,000 people reside in Jenkins County now, about 5,000 fewer than at the time of the lynching. The black population has plummeted — from about 8,700 and 60% of the population in 1920 to about 3,700 and 43% of the population today. Those thinning numbers can be seen in the Carswell Grove congregation.
But the church remains.
A shrinking congregation
On the day the church was burned to the ground — April 13, 1919 — an estimated 3,000 worshippers were there celebrating the church’s 52nd anniversary. The gothic-style church was rebuilt shortly after the attack. It fell into disrepair over the course of the next several decades, and a smaller church was built next to it in 2008. (The Gothic-style church was again burned down in 2014 in an arson that authorities never solved. It was not rebuilt.)
Now the congregation has only about 15 members, not enough to fill its 30 pews. The church holds service once a month.
The shrinking congregation has meant losing a connection to the stories of what happened on that day. And according to some residents, both black and white, people are reluctant to discuss it.
In that regard, Millen is much like the rest of the country. Historians say this chapter in American history has been neglected.
The violence of the Red Summer was caused by a series of circumstances that led to change throughout the country, they say. There was an economic downturn after the war. African American veterans came home from overseas ready to assert their rights more boldly. Black families, more mobile than ever, began migrating north and settling in white communities. Sensationalized newspaper accounts portrayed African Americans as a threat to the white way of life.
In Millen, most people still don’t know what happened there 100 years ago.
“Supposedly in the South we care about our heritage, but I find that there’s a lot of ignorance,” said Jesse Stone, a white state senator whose district includes Jenkins County.
Tendency toward neglect
Racial violence is nothing to be proud of, he said, so most people tend to shy from discussing it. “The tendency is more toward neglect,” he added.
“I think there’s genuine affection and very deep ties” between racial groups, said Stone, a Republican. “But I still think there’s a lack of understanding.”
Across the country, there are efforts to build awareness on the centennial anniversary.
In Elaine, Arkansas, the site of what is believed to be the deadliest Red Summer riot, residents, activists and academics gathered this year for a “truth telling” commission, and a memorial is under construction in a nearby town. Reporters have descended on the town to cover the 100th anniversary, and a documentary is in the works.
Some residents and historians say more than 200 African Americans were killed during the massacre in Elaine. Others say that number is vastly inflated. A memorial tree recently planted for the victims of the Elaine massacre was recently cut down in what some believe to be a hate crime.
In Millen, at the Chamber of Commerce along a sleepy quarter-mile drag of low-slung brick buildings that make up the historic district, Mandy Underwood, the executive director, and her sister, Holly Thompson, both white, said they had not heard of the events of 1919.
They flipped through a book of Jenkins County history to an entry about Carswell Grove. It said “the church was burned as a result of a racial conflict” but made no mention of the killings. “They just glossed over it,” said Thompson, 63. “That bothers me.”
When told the details of what happened, Thompson said it was an atrocity that should be known. “Some white people would be very embarrassed by something like that,” she said.
Learning about the ‘Red Summer’
Much of what is known about what happened in Millen comes from a 2012 book by Cameron McWhirter, “Red Summer: The Summer of 1919 and the Awakening of Black America.” According to McWhirter’s book, Joe Ruffin, a wealthy black landowner, got into a dispute with two white law enforcement officers who had taken one of his friends into custody.
Ruffin was shot in the head but survived. His sons and other African Americans retaliated and killed the two officers. The friend who was in police custody died in crossfire.
Word quickly spread, and an angry white mob set the Carswell Grove church ablaze. The mob killed two of Ruffin’s sons, throwing them into the burning church. It is unclear whether they were alive when they were thrown into the fire. Ruffin escaped. He was eventually acquitted of any wrongdoing in court, but he lost his land, two of his sons and his wealth. He was separated from his family and exiled to South Carolina.
“Joe Ruffin was building a kind of stable family,” said Judith Fennell Ruffin, the widow of Joe Ruffin’s great-grandson, John H. Ruffin Jr., who became a judge in Georgia. After the riot, “all of the stability that had been established was destroyed. Also, it took the family wealth. Then it was a sense of poverty,” she said.
Palmer Lewis and his family have been members of Carswell Grove for generations; his ancestors were among those who rebuilt the church after it burned down in 1919.
Lewis, 71, worked with the state’s historical society to get a dedication marker for the site. He also enlisted the help of the local chapter of the Sons of Confederate Veterans, having been friendly with its members over the years.
“If you learn your history, you’re bound not to repeat it again,” said Tommy Lane, who is the commander of the Millen branch of the Sons of Confederate Veterans and attended last year’s dedication ceremony.
Lane, 59, also said, when it came to racial animosity in 1919, “you had bad on both sides,” a statement that echoed a contentious remark that President Donald Trump made after white supremacists clashed with counterprotesters in Charlottesville, Virginia, two years ago.
For Lewis, to see the church’s history recognized with a permanent marker is what mattered most.
“My focus on this whole thing is a healing approach,” he said. “Hopefully, that will be in some hearts, minds, on both sides.”