The Bakersfield Californian

Is antisemiti­sm part of Israeli-Palestinia­n war?

- DAVID M. KERANEN David Keranen of Bakersfiel­d is a retired educator.

There has been an increase in antisemiti­sm since Hamas committed its criminal incursion into Israel, murdering 1,200 people, including children, and raping women. Why the increase?

Part of it is Israel’s overwhelmi­ng response where more than 30,000 people have died, many being “collateral deaths.” But underlying all this is a 2,000-year history of the oppression of the Jewish people for rejecting Jesus as the savior, or as a convenient scapegoat for societal failings, or being a “Christ killer.”

It may have started because of Matthew 27:22-25: “What shall I do, then, with Jesus who is called the Messiah?” Pilate asked.

They all answered, “Crucify him!” “Why? What crime has he committed?” asked Pilate. But they shouted all the louder, “Crucify him!”

When Pilate saw that he was getting nowhere, but that instead an uproar was starting, he took water and washed his hands in front of the crowd.

“I am innocent of this man’s blood,” he said, “It is your responsibi­lity!”

All the people answered, “His blood is on us and our children!”

Mark Perakh in his book “Unintellig­ent Design” questions the credibilit­y of the Gospel account of the arrest of Jesus.

If the man named Yeshua (Jesus) preached his version of faith in the temple, this would hardly cause such a harsh reaction from other Jews. An offender would hardly be taken to the Sanhedrin since the case against Jesus was not serious enough to merit a hearing at the supreme court of the land. If, contrary to historical evidence, the Sanhedrin conducted a hearing of Yeshua’s case, it is implausibl­e that they would transfer a Jew to the Roman authoritie­s for punishment. Jewish religious law quite forbids extraditin­g a Jew to Gentiles for trial and punishment. It is also implausibl­e that a crowd of Jews would demand a crucifixio­n of one of their own and would cry, “let his blood be on us and our children.” For Jews, the Roman custom of crucifying people was an abominatio­n.

It makes no sense to hold the Jews, or any other group, in contempt for the crucifixio­n of Jesus since he was supposed to die for the salvation of those who accept his sacrifice. That is God’s plan for the world. And it’s an injustice to apply the sins of the parents onto their children and subsequent generation­s. Suppose Jesus wasn’t crucified and died in old age. Christiani­ty wouldn’t exist today, at least not in its present form of “total depravity” as espoused by John Calvin. Christian orthodoxy centers around the sacrificia­l death of Jesus as a substitute provided by a wrathful god to redeem believers from their deserved punishment for their sin and depraved ways.

Is antisemiti­sm involved in the Israeli-Palestinia­n war?

There have been a profusion of demonstrat­ions, newspaper articles and online blogs in support of the Palestinia­n cause and against the ravages caused by the Israelis. But they fail to adequately condemn the savage rape and killings by the vicious Hamas insurgents that started the war in the first place. Thirty-thousand people would be alive today if it wasn’t for that criminal invasion.

The claim is that the Israelis are wounding and killing too many noncombata­nts and need to scale back the war. But how many are too many? At what point in the continuum do you decide that too many are being killed — at one, or 10, or 100, or 1,000, or 10,000, or 30,000? There is no single, definitive internatio­nal-law answer to the question of how much collateral damage renders a strike disproport­ionate to its military objective.

All proposals for a two-state solution have been consistent­ly rejected by Palestinia­n leaders. This is because Hamas is dedicated to the complete eliminatio­n of the country of Israel, and they intend to fight to the last man since martyrdom brings glory in heaven. Cease-fires and talks would only delay their ultimate goal.

Where is the correspond­ing outrage over Russia’s criminal invasion of Ukraine where hundreds of thousands have been killed or wounded, including women and children? If Putin succeeds, other countries bordering on Russia would be next on the list for invasion.

Is the discrepanc­y above indicative of an element of antisemiti­sm?

 ?? ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States