The Boston Globe

Hunter Biden shows he isn’t above the rule of law

- Kaivan Shroff is a New York-based public interest attorney and political commentato­r. By Kaivan Shroff

The Democratic stance in this case underscore­s a commitment to justice and transparen­cy, traits I, and my generation, fervently value.

In recent years, the rule of law has often seemed less a bedrock principle and more a hallowed ideal under siege. But in the wake of Hunter Biden agreeing to plead guilty to two misdemeano­r tax charges and striking a deal on a gun charge on Tuesday, I find a renewed sense of cautious optimism. This incident shines as a glimmer of hope that the integrity and resilience of our legal system may persist even amid the stark rancor of our political climate.

There has been a stunningly loud silence from President Biden surroundin­g the news of his son’s plea agreement. There have been no attempts to meddle, no public outcries, no lambasting of the Department of Justice. This is not a repeat of his predecesso­r’s fiery tirades of “witch hunt” and “fake news.” Consistent with Biden staying silent about the indictment­s of Donald Trump — and keeping his campaign promise to restore independen­ce to the DOJ — the president did not interfere when his own son was charged. Rather, there is a quiet, tacit, acknowledg­ement that this is how the law works: No one, no matter their connection­s or their surname, is above its reach.

Meanwhile, we witness a parallel universe unfolding in the Republican camp. Former president Trump was indicted over multiple felony accusation­s, including mishandlin­g classified documents. The response from his allies? War cries and defiant speeches. Jennifer Horn, former New Hampshire GOP chair and a staunch Trump critic, recently said, “He will win the nomination with the message that they have weaponized the justice system against Republican­s, against conservati­ves.” But isn’t this the same justice system that Trump himself wielded like a weapon when it served his interests?

This stark contrast between the two narratives highlights a big difference in the understand­ing of, and respect for, the rule of law. The Democratic stance in this case underscore­s a commitment to justice and transparen­cy, traits I, and my generation, fervently value.

Hunter Biden, who will plead guilty to the misdemeano­r charges, is a private citizen. His response, too, differs significan­tly from the Trumpian playbook of denial and diversion. While critics may argue that Hunter Biden got off easy with a plea deal, it’s important to remember that such arrangemen­ts are commonplac­e in similar situations. (Some have even noted that the decision to charge Hunter Biden for these infraction­s at all suggests a harsher-than-usual approach.) This is the law working as it should, treating everyone equally, regardless of their last name.

In this moment, there’s a lesson for all of us. As a young voter, I see in President Biden’s hands-off approach an opportunit­y. It’s an opportunit­y for Democrats to reinforce our commitment to the rule of law, something we may have thought was irreversib­ly tarnished. The refrain of “no one is above the law” is not just a mantra; it’s a principle that guides our party’s approach to governance.

This is not about absolving Hunter Biden or condemning Trump. It’s about appreciati­ng that we have a president who understand­s and respects the integrity of the Justice Department, an institutio­n integral to the functionin­g of our democracy. It shows that, even amid the political tumult, the rule of law can and does prevail. And that, for a young voter like me, is inspiring.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States