The Boston Globe

Her students were caught up in the murder investigat­ion. In ways that still gnaw at her, so was she.

-

Thank you for the front-page series “Nightmare in Mission Hill: The untold story of the Charles and Carol Stuart shooting.” It brought me to tears several times. I was a teacher at the old Mission High School on Alleghany Street in 1989.

The Boston police brought in a number of my male students as potential suspects.

It was shocking to me to learn later that so many people knew that an innocent man could possibly be executed for a crime he did not commit and yet chose to remain silent.

Carol Stuart’s murder caused a rupture between my mostly Black students and me that I’m not sure ever healed. As a white woman, I reflexivel­y and uncritical­ly embraced the narrative that Charles Stuart was a victim along with his wife and child. I accused my students of denial, and they, rightly, accused me of racism. I hope that I apologized to them afterward, but I doubt I had the maturity or self-assurance to do so. For that I am sorry.

Charles Stuart cynically exploited the racism that has long festered in this city. With a single utterance — “It was a black man” — he understood that any scrutiny of his involvemen­t would be erased by our collective instinctiv­e and unconsciou­s eagerness to think the worst about Black men.

This is the insidious nature of racism. As your series has shown, it didn’t just distort institutio­ns like the police and city government. It also corroded the essence of those of us who think of ourselves as good people but who nonetheles­s unwittingl­y bought into the Stuart narrative.

MARY BURNS Brighton

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States