Cost of prosperity
Residents, researchers question whether fracking has harmed eastern Ohio
Six years ago, oil and gas company Antero Resources showed up in Belmont County, promising money to a struggling community in exchange for rights to drill on Online
To see more about fracking in Belmont County, go to Dispatch.com/videos residents’ land.
Oil and gas companies promised thousands — and in some cases millions — in an area where an estimated 14% of county residents live below the federal poverty level.
Many in the community signed on.
In Barnesville, a village of about 4,000 people, 80% of landowners signed leases to allow Antero to drill for natural gas on or under their land. Schools have received an influx of money, and about 150 oil and gas jobs have been created in the county.
But now a growing number of residents in eastern Ohio are wondering whether they are paying too high a price for the fracking bonanza.
People “just heard money and they were lined up, you know, clear around the (Barnesville) high school. Hundreds and hundreds of people (were) waiting to get in to sign up. That was
very alarming to me just to see how blindly everyone embraced the industry,” said Jill Hunkler, a 44-year-old Barnesville resident who says she has suffered health problems because of the drilling.
Amid the drilling boom, environmentalists and health experts have descended upon Belmont and neighboring Appalachian counties in an effort to measure the impact of hydraulic fracturing, known as fracking, on water quality, air emissions and even emotional health.
“The evidence is strengthening and growing,” said Nicole Deziel, an assistant professor at the Yale School of Public Health, who has been visiting the region for three years to study air and water quality. “Scientists are quickly conducting health studies to better understand whether there are health impacts or not.”
Activists say the clock is ticking. They hope to have clear findings before the oil and gas industry takes a big next step.
Chemical company PTTGC America, based in Thailand, is considering building a “cracker” plant on the west bank of the Ohio River in Belmont County that would convert an oil and gas byproduct created by frackinginto ethylene, a key ingredient in producing plastics and chemicals. Such a plant could produce hundreds of high-paying jobs and potentially draw plastics plants seeking access to the ethylene.
This month, Jobsohio, the state’s economic development nonprofit agency, awarded a $30 million grant to ready the site, and PTTGC America already has invested more than $100 million to conduct engineering designs.
“I am very hopeful we’re going to get a final decision … and get to the point where they can move forward,” said Larry Merry, executive director of the Belmont County Port Authority.
The cracker plant would be the largest economic development project in the state.
Wiooers
The boom in drilling for oil and natural gas in Ohio is nowhere louder than in Belmont County, about 120 miles east of Columbus. It produced more natural gas and brine waste from the hydraulic fracturing process in the first quarter of this year than any other Ohio county, according to Ohio Department of Natural Resources data.
Plenty have benefited. Some families who own hundreds of acres and decided to lease their land to the fracking companiesare now millionaires. Larry Cain, 61, of Bethesda, and his family leased 280 acres. Cain, along with a group of 800 leaseholders, collectively leased 34,000 acres. Just to sign up, the group received more than $200 million.
“I would say probably everybody has a new pickup truck and they have newer tractors and equipment that’s safer to operate, but you don’t see ... what I would say is an extravagant lifestyle,” he said. “People remodel their kitchens — things like that — that was probably always needed but they never had the money to do it.”
Belmont County home prices have risen from a median sale price of $92,000 in September 2013 to $128,000 in September 2018, according to the East Central Association of Realtors. In addition, the state has collected $58.4 million in severance taxes from natural gas extraction, which funds the regulation of the industry.
Schools also have seen a jump in revenue from taxes collected on the gas and other minerals.
The St. Clairsvillerichland City School District is in the process of collecting $835,000 in fiscal years 2018 and 2019.
That money isn’t guaranteed.
The revenue so far has gone to one-time expenses such as new school buses, laptop computers and deferred maintenance.
Union Local Schools in Belmont County plans to use its gas-tax income on new heating and cooling systems and security upgrades, said Superintendent Ben Porter, who believes the industry on the whole has benefited the region, while acknowledging health concerns.
“There are more employment opportunities as a result, and environmental concerns. You do have those as well,” Porter said. “But from our standpoint, we have pretty good relationships with the oil and gas business. And it has been something that’s good just in terms of the extra revenue that it has generated.”
The industry has created jobs in Belmont County, though they can be measured in the hundreds, not the thousands, said Andrew Thomas, who works at the Energy Policy Center at Cleveland State University. But he says better jobs might be on their way.
“The new jobs in the oil and gas industry are not sufficient to offset the decline in other industries, particularly the coal industry,” Thomas said. “I think a lot of the jobs being created ... are not going to be really highpaying jobs, which is why we really want to see that cracker plant come in that can create more jobs that are in the construction and in higher-paying areas like plant management.”
Health effects
In 2012, there were nine wells drilled into the Utica shale layer of rock about a mile beneath Belmont County. As of June 29 of this year, there were 654 wells, 456 of which were producing. The county has eight wells in the Marcellus shale layer, which is not as deep as the Utica.
Wells are drilled to extract natural gas and oil from Devonian-age Marcellus shale and Ordovician-age Utica shale layers found in eastern Ohio. Once natural gas deposits are found, the companies drill down to the shale and the drill turns at a 90-degree angle. It can extend as much as a mile or more.
Then they inject millions of gallons of water, sand and chemicals underground to fracture the shale and free trapped oil and gas. Fracturing fluid including additives and chemicals is pumped in to fracture the rock, which allows oil and gas to be extracted.
Statewide, there were 400 Utica wells in 2012 and 3,117 wells as of June 29 of this year — a 679% increase. There are 67 Marcellus shale wells.
Scientists such as Yale’s Deziel are trying to study the effects of an industry that has expanded rapidly. There’s a lot at stake.
More than 4 million Americans live within a mile of unconventional oil and gas wells, which could subject them to toxic releases, according to a study released last year by Deziel and a team of other Yale researchers. More than 9 million Americans have drinking water sources within a mile of oil and gas wells.
In a study released last year by Yale researchers, 66 Belmont County residents were interviewed about health effects since the oil and gas boom. Many reported respiratory symptoms, general stress and fatigue and headaches, with
92% of people reporting at least one symptom.
The study did not find a specific connection between the drilling and health problems, but did support further analysis and monitoring to determine whether oil and gas activities were affecting drinking water.
Earlier this month, about 100 people attended a meeting at the Ohio Universitybranch campus in St. Clairsville to hear about a proposed injection well that would be used to storewastewater fromfracking waste in the county. They also heard more about Deziel’s research.
Mike Bianconi, 62, who is a township trustee for Pease Township in Belmont County, attended the meeting.
“I’m not worried about me. I’m worried about the next generation . ... Usually it takes a long time for things to come down,” he said.
Mike Chadsey, a lobbyist for the Ohio Oil and Gas Association, said no one has a reason to be concerned about health issues.
“I think it’s been studied ad nauseam. And I think if we had a problem with water, we’d know about it,” he said. “We’ve been doing this since 2011. If you go back to conventional development— 1880— if we had a problem, we’d know about it. We don’t.”
Hunkler, who has well water at her home in Barnesville, had water tested from nearby Slope Creek. A couple of contaminants were found, but at levels below the federal Environmental Protection Agency limit, according to the results. About a dozen contaminants were tested for in the first round of tests by Yale researchers a few years ago.
“I was really concerned about that . ... Of course, immediately I want to blame the industry, you know, but to be able to prove that that is the industry?” Hunkler said. Her well water is being examined during this latest round of tests by Yale researchers, who now will be testing for about 100 compoundsin the water.
Cain also is participating in the study a second time. He said the water near the land he’s been leasing out for fracking tested at safe levels a few years ago.
“If we truly believe that they’re doing this in a responsible way, we should be willing to participate in things like this. If they’re not, then we want to be aware of that and the company should respond to that,” he said.
Deziel said EPA drinking water standards have not been updated recently and might not reflect the most current research on safe levels. With more data, standards and guidelines are often altered. For example, for years, federal guidelines called for a much higher acceptable level of lead in blood.
“Now, scientists and doctors agree there is no safe level,” she said, citing the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Environmental questions
Hunkler lives about a mile from the Humphreys compressor station, which pressurizes and moves natural gas through the pipeline.
The facilities are required to track nitrogen oxide, carbon monoxide and volatile organic compound emissions. Nitrogen oxide and volatile organic emissions form ozone on hot days. High enough levels can cause respiratory issues for sensitive groups, such as those with asthma.
Markwest, a subsidiary of Marathon Petroleum that specializes in compressor stations, hired a third-party company, Air Hygiene Inc., in April to perform its tests. Ohio EPA allows companies to hire an outside company to test emission levels, and the results are submitted to the state agency.
“There is an obligation by the facility to report accurately. And there’s a pretty significant difficulty on the part of the facility to not do it properly. That will typically wash out through the inspection process,” said Bryon Marusak, manager of ambient air operations for air pollution control for the Ohio EPA.
Inspectors are trained thoroughly and initially have to partner with experienced colleagues. The people who collect the data for the company also are interviewed by state inspectors, he said.
Levels were well below guidelines for the Humphreys station, according to an inspection report. Records show the compressor station had one violation in 2016, when it went above permitted limits.
Fracking-related problems
Statewide, 293 spills, leaks or fires were reported at oil and gas sites in 2018. Fifteen incidents — including the most severe — were reported in Belmont County, according to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources. Statewide, the number was down slightly compared with 2017, when there were 311 incidents. As of June 30 of this year, there were 136 incidents.
In February 2018, workers lost control of a well and an unknown amount of fluid entered a tributary of Captina Creek. People were evacuated as far as a mile away.
Just two years earlier, a brine truck crash resulted in more than 4,000 gallons leaking into the reservoir.
In September 2018, there was a tanker crash that caused 840 gallons of production brine to be released into a nearby creek.
In neighboring Noble County, there have been a few reported explosions. One, reported in January 2018, “shook the house and flames were above the ridge line an estimated 200 feet,” according to ODNR reports.
“We were scared to death. The noise was horrific — like a jet engine. We were approximately 2 miles over on the next ridge, but we didn’t know that. It sounded and looked like the whole hillside had exploded and was on fire. We never felt safe ... after that,” said Kerri Bond, who has since moved to another state.
Belmont County Commissioner J.P. Dutton, who lives less than a mile from a well pad with his wife and young children, previously was a policy analyst in the energy industry. He said he believes the wells are safely managed.
“I put full faith in those individuals that spend their day-to-day activities focusing directly on those issues, whether it’s the U.S EPA, the Ohio EPA, the Ohio Department of Natural Resources,” he said. “When concerns come up, we try to direct those (concerned residents) to those individuals who can best answer those questions.”
bburger@dispatch.com @Bybethburger