Biden heads to Hill, as Dems scale back $3.5T plan
Holdout Manchin dashes hopes for a compromise
WASHINGTON – President Joe Biden headed to Capitol Hill on Friday as Democrats were determined to rescue a scaled-back version of his $3.5 trillion government overhaul and salvage a related public works bill after a long night
of frantic negotiations resulted in no deal.
The White House said Biden was set to meet with House Democrats in a private caucus meeting on steps forward. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi had earlier vowed there would be a “vote today” on the companion $1 trillion infrastructure bill that is popular but has become snared in the broader debate. But the situation was highly uncertain, and no schedule was set.
Holdout Democratic Sen. Joe Manchin
of West Virginia sank hopes for a compromise late Thursday, despite hours of shuttle diplomacy with White House aides on Capitol Hill, when he refused to budge on his demands for a smaller overall package, around $1.5 trillion. That’s too meager for progressive lawmakers who are refusing to vote on the public works measure without a commitment to Biden’s broader framework on the bigger bill.
Talks swirled over a compromise in the $2 trillion range. Because of the ongoing negotiations, Biden opted to remain in Washington on Friday instead of traveling to his Delaware home as he often does on weekends. His public approval rating has dropped, according to a new poll from The Associated PRESSNORC Center.
“We understand that we’re going to have to get everybody on board in order to be able to close this deal,” said Rep. Pramila Jayapal, D-washington, the leader of the Congressional Progressive Caucus. “We’re waiting for that.”
The president and his party are facing a potentially embarrassing setback – and perhaps a politically devastating collapse of the whole enterprise – if they cannot resolve the standoff.
At immediate risk was the promised vote on the first piece of Biden’s proposal, the slimmer $1 trillion public works bill, a roads-and-bridges package.
Biden’s bigger proposal is a years-inthe-making collection of Democratic priorities, a sweeping rewrite of the nation’s tax and spending policies that would essentially raise taxes on corporations and the wealthy and plow that money back into government health care, education and other programs.
Biden says the ultimate price tag is zero, because the tax revenue would cover the spending costs – higher rates on businesses earning more than $5 million a year, and individuals earning more than $400,000 a year, or $450,000 for couples.
The White House and Democratic leaders are intently focused on Manchin and to some extent Sen. Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona, two centrist Democrats who helped steer the public works bill to Senate
passage but have concerns that Biden’s bill is too big. The two senators have infuriated colleagues by not making specific counter-proposals public.
Manchin said has been clear from the start.
“I’m willing to sit down and work on the $1.5,” Manchin said as protesters seeking a bigger package and Biden’s priorities chanted behind him.
After hours of negotiations that stretched near midnight Thursday, he said he could not yet compromise. “I don’t see a deal tonight. I really don’t,” Manchin said.
Pelosi called it a “day of progress” in a letter to colleagues, but offered few other
words on the path forward.
White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki released a late-night statement saying: “A great deal of progress has been made this week, and we are closer to an agreement than ever. But we are not there yet, and so, we will need some additional time to finish the work.”
The political stakes could hardly be higher. Biden and his party are reaching for a giant legislative accomplishment – promising to deliver vision, dental and hearing care for seniors, free kindergarten for youngsters, strategies to tackle climate change and more – with a slim majority in Congress.
“We’ve been fighting for transformative legislation as all of you know; these discussions have gone on for month after month after month,” said Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-vermont, the chairman of the Budget Committee and a leading progressive lawmaker. “This is not a baseball game. This is the most significant piece of legislation in 70 years.”
With Republicans all opposed to the president’s big plan, deriding it as slide to socialist-style spending, Biden is reaching for a deal with members of his own party for a signature policy achievement.
The public works bill is one piece of that broader Biden vision, a $1 trillion investment in routine transportation, broadband, water systems and other projects bolstered with extra funding. It won bipartisan support in the Senate but has now become snared by the broader debate.
It’s not just Manchin’s demands to reduce the overall size, but the conditions he wants placed on new spending that will rile his more liberal colleagues as he works to ensure the aid goes only to lower-income people, rather than broader swaths of Americans. Tensions spiked late Wednesday when Manchin sent out a fiery statement, decrying the broad spending as “fiscal insanity.”
Sinema was similarly working to stave off criticism and her office said claims that she has not been forthcoming are “false” – though she has not publicly disclosed her views over what size package she wants and has declined to answer questions about her position.
Democrats’ campaign promises on the line, progressive lawmakers were fuming, sparks flying at the holdout senators.
Rep. Ilhan Omar, D-minnesota, another progressive leader, pointing her criticism clear at Manchin’s remarks.
“Trying to kill your party’s agenda is insanity. Not trying to make sure the president we all worked so hard to elect, his agenda pass, is insanity,” she said.