The Commercial Appeal

Sister-in-law jealous of attention paid to traumatize­d new mother

- At

Adapted from an online discussion. Dear Carolyn: The past two months of my life have been crazy. I was pregnant and broke my water about three months early. I had to stay in the hospital for five weeks so they could try to keep the baby in. Then I had a C-section and my baby almost died. The baby was in the NICU for a month after birth. During all of that, we were undertakin­g a kitchen renovation. Oh, and this was after three years of infertilit­y, surgery to remove my fibroid tumors, etc. Needless to say, my husband and I are exhausted.

However. My husband’s sister, after hearing we were expecting, decided to try to get pregnant ASAP (and succeeded) so our kids could be “close in age.” She already has two kids. But now she is upset that she’s not getting the same amount of attention we thankfully did from our friends, family, and community during our crazy time. She feels we didn’t show enough excitement when we found out her baby’s gender (our baby was still in the NICU at this point). She is upset people aren’t showing the same excitement over her pregnancy as they did for ours. She now has demanded that her mother throw a “sprinkle” for her because we had a shower.

Now my mother-in-law and husband say I need to attend this sprinkle for my sister-in-law and I’m frankly fed up. She’s always been a bit demanding and needy but I didn’t really care before. Now I don’t have the freaking energy to make sure we provide the correct amount of excitement for her third kid while we’re just recovering from a trauma.

My husband wants to keep the peace, plus my sister-in-law did do a lot for us and our kid.

Driving Me Nuts

Driving Me Nuts: Her needy dysfunctio­n is her problem. Your part is to decide whether and how you’ll engage with her (if at all), and for what purpose – then put that into practice.

So, for example: Your purpose can be to remain involved but sane as you support your husband in his peacekeepi­ng.

Your methods can be – again, just for example – to engage with your sister-inlaw only on your terms, often enough to evade detection but infrequent­ly enough not to get sucked in. Or just (eventually) through your kids.

You can also choose to engage with her in the easiest ways available. Thus events like “sprinkles”: You go, you smile, you leave.

… When you’re ready, though. Party attendance and strategic thinking on sister-in-law management don’t belong on a traumatize­d new mom’s to-do list. Congrats on your new little person. Re: Sprinkle: I would say skip it because you have a medically fragile baby. I would also say, as someone whose kiddo spent two months in the NICU: Please, please, please seek out a therapist. You will be amazed what can trigger a breakdown or a PTSD moment.


Anonymous: Right, of course, thanks. Best part, it’s a reason that is just beyond argument: Can’t risk exposing the child.

Post healing, though, to summarize: Think contained, strategic engagement. And yes to therapy if it’s accessible. Thanks again.

Email Carolyn

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States