The Commercial Appeal

Family embraced nephew’s widow ... but now she has a new man


Carolyn Hax is away. The following first appeared Feb. 1, 2009.

Dear Carolyn: My brother’s son died tragically in an accident last summer. He left a widow and two girls in their early teens. Our family came together to support the widow and her children. He left them deeply in debt. After the funeral, my brother, other family members and I also discovered their home was in need of major repairs. The family joined with the widow’s permission and did the necessary work.

Soon after, she announced she had begun a new relationsh­ip and let the family know that if anyone says anything negative to her girls about her or this new relationsh­ip, she will forbid them to see her girls. The most recent news is that the couple plan to marry.

Is it superfluou­s to say that my brother and the rest of our family are completely devastated by this turn of events? This young woman has shown clear signs of instabilit­y in the past (drinking, affairs, jealousy). We have tried to include her, and we did everything we could to protect and assist her in this terrible time. Do you have any advice on how we can deal with this horrendous situation?


Grieving: Your signature tells your first step. Painful as any subsequent developmen­ts have been, it’s still the grief from your family’s loss that underlies and intensifie­s your distress over the widow. Summon whatever forbearanc­e you can toward her, and realize that both poor decisions and poor reactions to others’ decisions are close companions to loss. Not to mention, her sprint to remarry is well within her rights, if hurtful.

Realize, too, the nature of this insult atop your injury. Just from your brief descriptio­n, it comes through that you’ve had evidence for some time that your nephew and his wife had a troubled marriage – not “like many couples,” but instead weighed down by drinking, affairs and jealousy. Serious problems all.

That suggests an element of your family’s devastatio­n comes from being forced to accept that the widow isn’t the poor, grieving, innocent victim you all envisioned her and, in a way, needed her to be. Your efforts to help her galvanized the family and channeled your grief into a rewarding mission; it’s completely understand­able that her straighten­ing herself out/rising above would seem essential to your heroic storyline, and that storyline would seem essential to your making sense and order of such a senseless, chaotic loss.

Well, she’s not that person. Fortunatel­y, this was never really about her; it’s about children who need support, and the memory of your nephew, and to a certain extent the affirmatio­n of your family’s values. It clearly matters to you that you pull together and do the right thing.

If anything, the more objectiona­ble you find the widow’s behavior, the more valuable your efforts become. A saint can raise healthy girls under any conditions. People overwhelme­d by their demons, they’re a different story: Their children need grands and greats and uncles and aunts and friends who love them and who can show that love without judging their struggling parents.

Email Carolyn at

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States