Big tobacco: top US arts institutions under fire for accepting donations
Researchers are questioning why some American museums accept tobacco donations, even as some review donation policies in light of the UK National Portrait Gallery recently rejecting a gift from the Sackler family, owner of Purdue Pharma who are at the center of America’s devastating opioid crisis.
One of America’s most venerated institutions, the Smithsonian museum, which oversees the US National Portrait Gallery, has accepted donations from the US maker of Marlboro cigarettes as recently as 2017.
The Smithsonian is not alone. In 2018, Altria donated $3.6m to arts and culture institutions, a spokesman told the Guardian. The Newseum and the John F Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts in Washington DC and New York’sAlvin Ailey American Dance Theater all accepted Altria funding that year, according to the latest available company documents.
In 2014, the Landmark Theater in Richmond, Virginia, also struck a sponsorship deal with Altria, and was renamed the “Altria Theater” in exchange for $10m from the tobacco company.
Dr Michael Siegel, a professor of health sciences at Boston University and an expert in tobacco marketing, said he was “shocked to even hear” the Smithsonian, among others, continued to accept donations from tobacco companies.
“I’m surprised to hear in 2017, or possibly now, that there are major institutions that are taking tobacco money. It’s a surprise to me,” said Siegel. “If that was more widely known, there would be quite an outcry from people in the anti-tobacco movement.”
“When organizations accept money from big tobacco, they’re essentially
allowing themselves to be used by pawns in the marketing strategy of big tobacco companies,” said Siegel. He continued that accepting donations from tobacco companies was “extremely egregious at this point in that game”.
Last week, the UK’s National Portrait Gallery refused a donation of more than £1m from a Sackler family foundation, citing concerns about America’s opioid crisis. The Tate gallery group followed, and within days the Sackler Trust announced it would suspend giving in while roughly 2,000 opioid-related lawsuits move through courts.
Every day in the US, more than 130 people die of opioid-related drug overdoses, roughly 47,000 a year. The Sackler family’s blockbuster drug OxyContin, a powerful painkiller aggressively marketed by Purdue, is blamed with touching off the crisis.
By comparison, tobacco-related illness kills 1,300 people daily in the US, or 480,000 annually, accounting for roughly one in five deaths each year, according to the National Institutes on Drug Abuse.
Health authorities in the US are also concerned about an “epidemic” of teen vaping. Altria invested $12.8bn in Juul Labs, the dominant vaping company which is outperforming Wall Street’s expectations. An analyst said last week the company is on track to become the “Marlboro of e-vapor”. Philip Morris International is also pushing vaping, and struck a deal with the youthoriented Vice Media to promote its IQOS vape device.
“All companies donate to museums for similar reasons,” said Elizabeth Smith, a professor of behavioral sciences at University of California San Francisco’s Center for Tobacco Control Research and Education. “They want this social acceptance, and they can have this party and hang out with the movers and shakers who might make policy that is good for them.
“It’s just companies like tobacco companies or Purdue Pharma, in a sense, have even more need of it because they have a lot more reputation management work to do, because their inherent reputations are so poor,” she said.
One of the largest arts institutions to accept tobacco industry funding is the Smithsonian Institution in Washington DC, including incidentally, the Smithsonian’s Sackler Gallery. The Smithsonian oversees the US National Portrait Gallery.
The Smithsonian told the Guardian private donations were “critical” to the institution, and that Altria’s support dates back to 1983. “Virtually all major exhibitions are privately funded,” said a spokeswoman, Linda St Thomas.
“The company is a regular donor to Smithsonian exhibits in various museums and most recently contributed $500,000 to the National Museum of African American History and Culture for a WWI exhibit opening in September,” St Thomas said. “Altria is a corporate member of the Smithsonian which requires a minimum of $25,000 per year.”
A spokesman for Altria said: “Altria and its operating companies have a sixdecade history of corporate sponsorships to support artistic institutions to increase community access to highquality arts and cultural experiences.”
The Whitney Museum historically enjoyed a particularly close relationship with Philip Morris. The museum operated a satellite gallery at Philip Morris headquarters on Fifth Avenue in New York for 25 years. The branch shut down in 2007 when Philip Morris split into two companies, and Altria moved to Virginia.
In 2009, the company donated 150 works to the museum, including for example, the pop art painting Tobacco Rhoda by Mel Ramos, which pictures a naked woman sitting on a pack of Philip Morris cigarettes, a self-portrait by Philip Guston in which he is smoking, and an Andy Warhol lithograph of Elizabeth Taylor.
The Whitney did not respond to a Guardian inquiry about Altria.
American museums and arts institutions have had a long historical relationship with Philip Morris. The New York Sun reported in 2007 that institutions which enjoyed the tobacco company’s support included famous names such as the Brooklyn Academy of Music , the Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts and the New Museum of Contemporary Art.
Philip Morris also provided millions to explicitly sponsor art exhibits between the 1960s and late 1990s. The Metropolitan Museum of Art’s 1983 exhibit The Vatican Collection: Papacy and Art was paid for with a $3m grant from Philip Morris, and its 1993 exhibit of Henri Matisse’s work received a little less than half of its $5m budget from Philip Morris.