Lead in Michigan city’s tap water declines after rising for three years
The amount of lead in Benton Harbor, Michigan’s drinking water has declined, new testing shows, after three straight years of elevated results compelled residents to consume bottled water and prompted a hurried effort to replace old pipes.
Lead levels in the majority Black city’s drinking water are now just within standards set by the state that if exceeded, force a utility to take corrective action and inform residents of a problem, according to state officials.
Residents have worried about the effect on their families’ health, as lead can slow cognitive development and is especially dangerous for children.
Michigan officials said the new results indicate that corrosion control to prevent pipes from leaching lead into drinking water is helping. But the nearly 10,000 residents of Benton Harbor should still use bottled water for basic activities such as drinking and cooking, officials said.
“Everything is going to continue as it has previously, it’s just that the data is showing us that the corrosion control is working. We need to keep at it, keep improving it and keep working at it,” said Eric Oswald, director of the division that oversee drinking water at the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy.
Some community activists noted that the lead levels in the city’s water were now just barely below the federal limits, which many experts say need to be lowered. The Centers for Disease Control says no amount of lead is considered safe.
“Nobody should be taking a victory lap,” said the Rev Edward Pinkney, chair of the Benton Harbor Community Water Council. “The lead levels are still 15 parts per billion – and that’s unacceptable.”
The state provides free bottled water for Benton Harbor’s residents, but picking it up can be time consuming and tasks like cooking can quickly use up personal supplies. Homebound residents can ask for deliveries.
Since early 2019, residents have been offered free at-home filters designed to remove lead from the tap. In October, the state said it was reviewing the effectiveness of those filters “out of an abundance of caution” and issued guidance for residents to broadly use bottled water.
Oswald said preliminary results indicate the filters are working properly, but it will take until the first few months of next year for the Environmental Protection Agency to finish the study and confirm results.
Once the study is complete, state officials will decide whether filters are sufficiently reliable or bottled water should continue to be broadly used, Oswald said.
Benton Harbor’s recent water system tests reveal 15 parts per billion of lead; any more and it would exceed Michigan standards. Testing from earlier in the year produced levels of 24 ppb.
The highest site sampled had 48ppb of lead. Testing from earlier in the year produced a few results in the hundreds of parts per billion.
In the wake of the Flint water crisis, Michigan passed the nation’s tightest requirements for reducing lead in drinking water, implementing new testing standards and timelines for lead pipe replacement. Despite those changes, advocacy groups in September told the EPA in a petition that city and state officials had not acted quickly enough to address Benton Harbor’s problems.
Across the US, millions of lead service lines are underground. The recently passed infrastructure bill secured $15bn for lead service line replacement and the reconciliation package pending in Congress includes billions more – money that advocates have said is vital but will not be enough to remove every lead pipe.
Pinkney noted that the city still had an estimated 6,000 lead service lines connecting residents to its water system that needed to be replaced.
“Let’s work on removing all the lead pipes, before we take any victory laps,” he said.