The Guardian view on Whitby’s secondhome referendum: highlighting a national crisis
The motives behind this week’s referendum on second homes in the North Yorkshire town of Whitby were summed up by a resident who has lived there since she was a child. “It’s not that we’re against tourism; we’re not,” Sandra Turner told reporters. “But we don’t want to give up our town either.”
Albeit on a low turnout, the ballot delivered a 93% majority in favour of banning the future sale of new-builds to non-locals. Organised by community activists, the vote may or may not be heeded by the borough council. But a message has been sent, and the referendum will have struck a chord in many other scenic locations. Whitby, where house prices rose by 17% last year, is not alone in feeling somewhat besieged. In rural villages and picturepostcard towns, there is a sense that locals are being priced out and social cohesion eroded by a rising tide of outside investment.
The ban on foreign travel during the pandemic saw the price of homes shoot up in such places, as spending on holiday residences boomed. But the trend predates Covid. Between 2015 and 2021, there was an estimated 1,000% increase nationally in shortterm lets, with most of the increase in rural holiday hotspots. Meanwhile, long-term rental opportunities are vanishingly rare, and affordable homes in scandalously short supply. Just along the coast from Whitby, in Robin Hood’s Bay, there is an estimated 70:30 split between holiday-home owners and villagers. Tim Farron, the Liberal Democrat MP for Westmorland and Lonsdale, has said that rural Britain’s housing crisis is moving from “crisis to catastrophe”.
What is to be done? The money that temporary residents spend – and the building and maintenance of the places where they stay – constitutes a vital pillar of local economies. Many second-home owners form deep bonds with places that become part of the fabric of their lives. But a town is not a business, set up to service the requirements of visitors and provide rich returns for property investors. It is a place with a history and an identity – one sustained by successive generations who have lived there permanently.
That sense of community is undermined when locals are forced to move elsewhere because they cannot afford to stay, and when rural schools are halfempty because of a dearth of young families. As social housing waiting lists continue to lengthen, along with the numbers of homeless people, it is unacceptable that such a high proportion of properties – many bought purely for investment purposes – lie empty for much of the year.
A rebalancing, to help communities to shape their own destiny and cater for local needs, is overdue. There are signs that one is partially under way. In Wales, a hefty 300% council tax premium on second homes will be permitted from 2023. The government’s levelling up bill allows for a doubling of council tax on second homes in England. But homes rented out as holiday lets are able to avoid council tax and move to business rates.
A more fundamental paradigm shift may be required. Mr Farron has called for councils to be granted new powers
to control and cap the number of second homes and holiday lets in their area. That seems like a sensible approach. Local people and their representatives should be given the political levers necessary to protect the integrity and texture of the places in which they live.