‘Gratuitous, inaccurate’: White House disputes special counsel report on Biden
Democrats and the White House on Friday launched an aggressive push back against a special counsel report that pushed Joe Biden’s age and memory to the front and center of the presidential election campaign and spurred a series of Republican attacks on the US president.
The special counsel Robert Hur’s report on Biden’s handling of confidential documents on Thursday said the US president would not face criminal charges in the case but in a series of remarks characterized Biden as elderly and with a failing memory – triggering a political bombshell on an issue seen as a core weakness of Biden’s re-election campaign.
“He gets it. He gets how he’s viewed. He gets what people see and what’s written about him and what the American people also see. But there are other things to know,” the White House spokesperson Karine Jean-Pierre said, pointing to reports that the former Republican House speaker Kevin McCarthy considered the president a sharp negotiator.
In an unusually lengthy question and answer session with the White House press corps other Biden administration officials also joined the chorus of voices defending the president, his lengthy legislative record in his first term as president and his handling of a multitude of crises – both domestic and foreign.
The White House spokesperson Ian Sams said he fundamentally disagreed with the special counsel’s description’s of Joe Biden’s ability to recall details. “I dispute that the characterizations about his memory in the report are accurate, because they’re not,” he said as he and Jean-Pierre faced a barrage of questions on the issue.
Sams also indicated that it was possible transcripts of Biden’s interviews with Hur’s team could be released. The transcripts could shine some light on some of the more jarring comments about the president’s memory Hur made in his report, such as that he could not recall the years he was vice-president, or when his son, Beau Biden, died.
Democrats have also been quick to compare Biden’s issues with that of his almost certain rival in the 2024 race – the former US president Donald Trump. Trump also faces political problems due to his handling of confidential documents, but unlike Biden, he is being prosecuted for obstructing the recovery of papers held at his Mar-aLago resort in Florida.
Trump also regularly makes gaffes on the campaign trail and faces a raft of other criminal charges in relation to his business dealings, allegedly paying off an adult film star, his role in the January 6 attack on the Capitol and trying to subvert the 2020 election in Georgia.
But that did not stop the former US president and his many loyal allies in the Republican party from going on the offensive and seeking to portray Biden as mentally unfit for office.
That barrage of attacks was met by a firm response from Democrats.
The vice-president, Kamala Harris, condemned Hur’s comments about Biden’s age and memory as “gratuitous, inaccurate and inappropriate”, and noted that the president’s interview was conducted in the “intense” aftermath of the 7 October terrorist attack in Israel.
“The way that the president’s demeanor in that report was characterized could not be more wrong on the facts, and clearly politically motivated, gratuitous,” she said.
The Pennsylvania Democratic sen
ator John Fetterman said he believes Biden is still up to the job as president, and criticized Hur as having concocted a “smear job”. The senator added: “The president was very clear in that he is absolutely in full control.”
The Wisconsin Democratic senator Tammy Baldwin said: “I judge a president on what they’ve done and whose side they’re on,” Baldwin told the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. She pointed to Biden’s “strong record of creating good-paying jobs, rebuilding our infrastructure, and lowering prescription drug prices”.
Similarly, the Wisconsin Democratic congressman Mark Pocan stated that Biden “got things done for the
American people”, while Trump “has used hate to try to divide this nation and in a way unseen before”.
Not all Democrats were quite so unified, especially as polling has shown that many Americans – including Democrats – consider Biden’s age a source of deep concern. Paul Begala, a former top aide to Bill Clinton and now a CNN commentator said: “I’m a
Biden supporter and I slept like a baby last night – I woke up every two hours crying and wet the bed. This is terrible for Democrats.”
In a policy response to the issue the Biden administration plans to appoint a taskforce to review how classified documents are handled during often chaotic transitions between presidential administrations. Aside from
Biden and Trump, Trump’s ex-vice president, Mike Pence, was also found to have some confidential documents inadvertently in his possession.
“The president’s going to appoint a taskforce to review how transitions look at classified material to ensure that there are better processes in place,” Sams said.