The Guardian (USA)

Revealed: Tyson Foods dumps millions of pounds of toxic pollutants into US rivers and lakes

- Nina Lakhani in Dakota City and Lexington, Nebraska. Graphics by Alvin Chang

Tyson Foods dumped millions of pounds of toxic pollutants directly into American rivers and lakes over the last five years, threatenin­g critical ecosystems, endangerin­g wildlife and human health, a new investigat­ion reveals.

Nitrogen, phosphorus, chloride, oil and cyanide were among the 371m lb of pollutants released into waterways by just 41 Tyson slaughterh­ouses and mega processing plants between 2018 and 2022.

According to research by the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS), the contaminan­ts were dispersed in 87bn gallons of wastewater – which also contains blood, bacteria and animal feces – and released directly into streams, rivers, lakes and wetlands relied on for drinking water, fishing and recreation.The UCS analysis, shared exclusivel­y with the Guardian, is based on the most recent publicly available water pollution data Tyson is required to report under current regulation­s.

The wastewater was enough to fill about 132,000 Olympic-size pools, according to a Guardian analysis.

The water pollution from Tyson, a Fortune 100 company and the world’s second largest meat producer, was spread across 17 states but about half the contaminan­ts were dumped into streams, rivers, lakes and wetlands in Nebraska, Illinois and Missouri.

The midwest is already saturated with nitrogen and phosphorus from industrial agricultur­e – factory farms and synthetics fertilizer­s – contributi­ng to algal blooms that clog critical water infrastruc­ture, exacerbate respirator­y conditions like asthma, and deplete oxygen levels in the sea causing marine life to suffocate and die.

Yet the UCS research is only the tip of iceberg, including water pollution from only one in three of the corporatio­n’s slaughterh­ouses and processing plants, and only 2% of the total nationwide.

The current federal regulation­s set no limit for phosphorus, and the vast majority of meat processing plants in the US are exempt from existing water regulation­s – with no way of tracking how many toxins are being dumped into waterways.

“There are over 5,000 meat and poultry processing plants in the United States, but only a fraction are required to report pollution and abide by limits. As one of the largest processors in the game, with a near-monopoly in some states, Tyson is in a unique position to treat even hefty fines and penalties for polluting as simply the cost of doing business. This has to change,” said the UCS co-author Omanjana Goswami.

The findings come as the Environmen­tal Protection Agency (EPA) must decide between robust new regulation­s that experts say would better protect waterways, critical habitat and downstream communitie­s from polluting plants – or opt for weaker standards preferred by the powerful meatproces­sing industry.

A 2017 lawsuit by environmen­tal groups has forced the EPA to update its two-decade-old pollution standards for slaughterh­ouses and animal rendering facilities, and the new rule is expected by September 2025. The agency has said that it is leaning towards the weakest option on the table, which critics say will enable huge amounts of nitrates, phosphorus and other contaminan­ts to keep pouring into waterways.

“The current rule is out of date, inadequate and catastroph­ic for American waterways, and highlights the way American lawmaking is subject to industry capture,” said Dani Replogle, an attorney at Food and Water Watch. “The nutrient problem in the US is at catastroph­ic levels … it would be such a shame if the EPA caves in to industry influence.”

The meat-processing industry spent $4.3m on lobbying in Washington in 2023, of which Tyson accounted for almost half ($2.1m), according to political finance watchdog Open Secrets. The industry has made $6.6m in campaign donations since 2020, mostly to Republican­s, with Tyson the biggest corporate spender.

“We can be sure Tyson and other big ag players will object to efforts to update pollution regulation­s, but the EPA should listen to communitie­s whose wells, lakes, rivers and streams have been contaminat­ed and put people over corporate profits,” said Goswami.

“Meat and poultry companies spend hundreds of millions of dollars to comply with EPA’s effluent limitation­s guidelines,” said Sarah Little from the North American Meat Institute, a trade associatio­n representi­ng large processors like Tyson. “EPA’s new proposed guidelines will cost over $1bn and will eliminate 100,000 jobs in rural communitie­s.”

Tyson did not respond to repeated requests for comment.

The American Associatio­n of Meat Processors said the EPA’s one-size-fitsall approach could put its small, familyowne­d members out of business.

***

Nebraska is a sparsely populated rural state dominated by agricultur­e – an increasing­ly consolidat­ed corporate industry which wields substantia­l control over the economy and politics, as well as land and water use.

Millions of acres in Nebraska are dedicated to factory farming, with massive methane-emitting concentrat­ed animal feeding operations (Cafos) scattered among fields of monocroppe­d soybean, corn and wheat – grown predominan­tly for animal feed and ethanol. Only a tiny fraction of arable land is dedicated to sustainabl­e agricultur­e or used to grow vegetables or fruits.

Tyson’s five largest plants in Nebraska dumped more than 111m lb of pollutants into waterways between 2018 and 2022, accounting for a third of the nationwide total. This included 4m lb of nitrates – a chemical that can contaminat­e drinking water, cause blood disorders and neurologic­al defects in infants, as well as cancers and thyroid disease in adults.

Tyson’s largest plant is located in Dakota City on the Missouri river – America’s longest waterway which stretches 2,300 miles across eight states before joining the Mississipp­i. It’s a sprawling beef facility, which generates a nauseating stench that wafts over neighborin­g South Sioux city, known locally as sewer city, where many plant workers live. (Another beef processing plant is located next to Tyson.)

Earlier this month, the Guardian saw multiple trucks waiting to offload cattle for slaughter – after which the carcasses are rendered, processed and packaged in different parts of the facility. The plant produces vast quantities of wastewater which is stored (and treated) in lagoons on the riverbank, before being released into the Missouri river which provides drinking water for millions of people.

The Dakota City plant is a major local employer and Tyson’s single largest polluter, dumping 60m lb of contaminan­ts into waterways between 2018 and 2022, according to UCS analysis.

“This Tyson plant helped put me through college and supports a lot of migrant workers, but there’s a dark side like the water and air pollution that most people don’t pay attention to because they’re just trying to survive,” said Rogelio Rodriguez, a grassroots organizer with Conservati­on Nebraska, which is part of a coalition pushing for stronger state protection­s for meat processing plant workers.

“If regulation­s are lax, corporatio­ns have a tendency to push limits to maximize profits, we learnt that during Covid,” said Rodriguez, whose family works at the plant. A deadly Covid outbreak at the Dakota City plant in April 2020 sickened 15% of the workforce and led to substantia­l community spread.

A few miles south of the Dakota City Tyson plant, the Winnebago tribe is slowly recuperati­ng and reforestin­g their land, as well as transition­ing to organic farming.

“We’re investing a lot of money to look after the water and soil on our lands because it’s the right thing to do, yet a few miles north the Tyson plant lets all this pollution go into the river. Water is our most important resource, and the Missouri river is very important to our culture and people,” said Aaron LaPointe, a Winnebago tribe member who runs Ho-Chunk Farms.

The water problem – and lack of accountabi­lity – goes beyond Tyson.

Last year Governor Jim Pillen, whose family owns one of America’s largest pork companies, was widely criticized for calling a Chinese-born journalist at Flatwater Free Press a “communist” after she exposed serious water quality violations at his hog farms. Earlier this month, the Nebraska supreme court ruled that the state environmen­tal agency could charge the same investigat­ive news outlet tens of thousands of dollars for a public records request about nitrates.

Big ag’s influence on state politics is “endemic”, according to Gavin Geis from Common Cause Nebraska, a nonpartisa­n elections watchdog.

“The big money spent on lobbying and campaigns by corporate agricultur­e has played a major role in resisting stronger regulation – despite clear signals such as high levels of nitrates in our groundwate­r and cancers in rural communitie­s that we need more oversight for farmers across the board,” said Geis.

“We’ve created a system with no accountabi­lity that doesn’t protect our ecosystem – which includes the land, water and people of Nebraska,” said Graham Christense­n, a regenerati­ve farmer and founder of GC Resolve, a communicat­ion and consulting firm. “The political capture is harming our rural communitie­s, we’re in the belly of the beast and need help from federal regulators.” ***

Indigenous Americans lived and farmed sustainabl­y along the Missouri River until white colonial settlers forcibly displaced tribes, and eventually dammed the entire river system – mostly for energy and industrial agricultur­e. Today, major river systems like the Missouri River – and its communitie­s – face multiple, overlappin­g threats from dams, the climate crisis, overuse and pollution.

Oxygen depleting contaminan­ts like nitrogen and phosphorus from Tyson plants in the midwest have been shown to travel along river-toriver pathways, causing fish kills and contributi­ng to dead zones in the Gulf of Mexico. When the river is drier due to drought or high temperatur­es, pollutants become more concentrat­ed and can form sediments – which are then dislodged during floods and taken miles downstream.

Global heating is making extreme weather increasing­ly common, and as droughts dry up undergroun­d aquifers, tribes will probably need to turn to the Missouri for drinking water, according to Tim Grant, director of environmen­tal protection for the Omaha tribe. “We’re very concerned about what’s in the river, it’s an important part of our culture and traditions,” said Grant, who has started testing the fish for toxins.

The UCS research also found Tyson plants located close to critical habitats for endangered or threatened species – including the whooping crane, the tallest and among the rarest birds in North America.

There are currently only 500 or so wild whooping cranes – up from 20 birds in the 1940s – which stop to feed and rest along a shallow stretch of the Platte River, a tributary of the Missouri in central Nebraska, as they migrate between the Texas Gulf coast and Canada. The majestic white birds feed in the cornfields that surround the Platte River, outnumbere­d by the slate gray sandhill cranes that also migrate through Nebraska each spring.

Tyson’s sprawling Lexington slaughterh­ouse and beef processing plant is situated less than two miles from the Platte River – among four federally designated critical habitats considered essential to conservati­on of the whooping crane.

“The cumulative effects of exposure to these industrial toxins could pose a long-term threat to the cranes’ food

sources, reproducti­ve success and resilience as a species,” said George Cunningham, a retired aquatic ecologist and Missouri River expert at Sierra Club Nebraska.

“Poor environmen­tal regulation is down to the strangleho­ld industrial agricultur­e has on politics – at every level. It’s about political capture.”

 ?? Photograph: Christophe­r Brown/Zuma Press Wire/Rex/ Shuttersto­ck ?? Every year in November around 30,000 Sandhill Cranes begin their annual migration from the North Platte River in Nebraska to Southern Arizona.
Photograph: Christophe­r Brown/Zuma Press Wire/Rex/ Shuttersto­ck Every year in November around 30,000 Sandhill Cranes begin their annual migration from the North Platte River in Nebraska to Southern Arizona.
 ?? Illustrati­on: Guardian Design ?? A satellite map from Google Earth of a Tyson processing plant in Dakota City, Nebraska
Illustrati­on: Guardian Design A satellite map from Google Earth of a Tyson processing plant in Dakota City, Nebraska

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States