The Guardian (USA)

Clownfall: don’t be taken in by the trick of a great dictator

- York, US Elmhurst,New

I thank Adrian Chiles for drawing attention to Adolf Hitler’s chilling quote from the 1920s: “It makes no difference whatever whether they laugh at us or revile us … whether they represent us as clowns or criminals; the main thing is that they mention us, that they concern themselves with us again and again…” (Everyone laughed at Hitler in the 1920s. A century on, are we making the same mistake?, 24 April).

As a very young child, I lived through the second world war in Dublin; while Ireland was neutral, the war was nonetheles­s very present to us there. Like Chiles, all my life I have wondered how millions of people could have been taken in by a figure such as Hitler, with terrible consequenc­es.

And while there may be significan­t difference­s between Hitler and a certain figure south of the Canadian border, it’s not hard to see the ploy that was advocated in the quote that so chilled Chiles being employed by the latter – and successful­ly, to judge by much media coverage.David BlackwellE­astern Passage, Nova Scotia, Canada

• Adrian Chiles’s column was excellent. As a liberal American, I take the danger that is Donald Trump very seriously. I, and most of my circle of contacts and friends, understand that half the electorate in the US will vote for Trump, irrespecti­ve of anything he does or any court proceeding. We find this very frightenin­g.

I would like to think that some, if not most, liberal voters have thought this through, particular­ly after the 2020 election and its aftermath. It’s vital that some journalist­s finally have chosen to puncture the fragile facade that is the reliabilit­y of American democracy.Gary Rintelmann­Mequon,Wisconsin, US

• I have to agree that political leaders who are laughed at, such as Hitler, still have the potential to rise into power and produce destructiv­e outcomes. I have read many books on Hitler and 20th-century history. While there was a unique set of circumstan­ces that helped propel him into power, his narcissist­ic belief in himself and a fanatical determinat­ion to fulfil his imagined destiny are basic human traits (found mostly in men) and will always be present in the human race until one of them finally wipes all of us from this planet.Ed StrosserEa­st

 ?? ?? Charlie Chaplin as Adenoid Hynkel in the US film The Great Dictator (1940). Photograph: Ronald Grant Archive
Charlie Chaplin as Adenoid Hynkel in the US film The Great Dictator (1940). Photograph: Ronald Grant Archive
 ?? Photograph: AP ?? Juliane Koehler as Eva Braun and Bruno Ganz as Adolf Hitler in the German film Downfall (2004).
Photograph: AP Juliane Koehler as Eva Braun and Bruno Ganz as Adolf Hitler in the German film Downfall (2004).

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States