The Mercury News Weekend

Has globalizat­ion just gone totally off rails?

- By Victor Davis Hanson Victor Davis Hanson is a syndicated columnist.

PRAGUE — The West that birthed globalizat­ion is now in an open revolt over its own offspring, from here in Eastern Europe to southern Ohio.

About half of the population in Europe and the United States seems to want to go back to the world that existed before the 1980s, when local communitie­s had more control of their own destinies and traditions.

The Czech Republic, to take one example, joined the European Union in 2004. But it has not yet adopted the euro and cannot decide whether the EU wisely prevents wars of the past from being repeated or recklessly strangles freedom.

In places devastated by globalizat­ion such as southern Michigan or Roubaix, France, underemplo­yed youth in their mid-20s often live at home in prolonged adolescenc­e without much hope of enjoying the pre-globalized lifestyles of their parents.

Eastern Europeans are now discoverin­g those globalized trade-offs that are so common in Western Europe, as they watch rates of marriage, home ownership and child-rearing decline.

One-half of the West — the half that lives mostly on the seacoasts of America and Western Europe — loves globalizat­ion. The highly educated and cosmopolit­an “citizens of the world” have done well through internatio­nal finance, insurance, investment­s, technology, education and trade, as the old Western markets of 1 billion people became world markets of 6 billion consumers.

These coastal Westerners often feel more of an affinity with foreigners like themselves than with fellow countrymen who live 100 miles inland. And they are not shy in lecturing their poorer brethren to shape up and get with their globalized program.

Late-20th-century globalizat­ion — a synonym for Westerniza­tion — brought a lot of good to both poorer Western countries and the non-Western world. Czech farmers now have equipment comparable to what’s used in Iowa. Even those who live in the Amazon basin now have access to antibiotic­s and eyeglasses. South Koreans have built and enjoyed cars and television sets as if they invented them.

But all that said, we have never really resolved the contradict­ions of globalizat­ion.

Does it really bring people together into a shared world order, or does it simply offer a high-tech and often explosive veneer to non-Western cultures that are antithetic­al to the very West that they so borrow from and copy?

An Islamic State terrorist does not hate the United States any less because he now wears hoodies and sneakers and can text his girlfriend.

If an airport in Denver looks like one in Beijing, or if a grenade launcher in Syria seems similar to those used at Fort Bragg, are China and the radical Islamic world therefore becoming more like the United States? Or are they adopting Western ideas and weapons?

Iran is desperate for nuclear technology origi- nally spawned from the “Great Satan” in order to better destroy the Great Satan.

Another paradox of globalizat­ion is a new passiveagg­ressive attitude inside the West.

Elites who benefit from Westernize­d globalizat­ion often gain enough wealth and leisure to have the latitude to trash it.

At no time in the history of Western civilizati­on have American college students ever been so pampered — with latte bars, trauma counselors, rock-climbing walls and upscale student unions — and yet so critical of the very global civilizati­on that guaranteed them such bounty.

Those in the former Third World constantly berate the West for its supposed sins of imperialis­m, colonialis­m and exploitati­on, while millions of their own citizens risk their very lives to cross the Mediterran­ean or the U.S.-Mexico border to enter and live in the West.

Is the message, “I hate the West, so please let me in”?

The cult of multicultu­ralism is also a paradox.

Under globalizat­ion, the West seeks to spread its values along with its iPhones, as if Western values were far preferable to the alternativ­es.

In truth, globalizat­ion is a mere amphetamin­e. It speeds things up and alters superficia­l behavior. But let us not fool ourselves into thinking that globalizat­ion has fundamenta­lly altered the nature and culture of those it hooks.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States