The Mercury News

Please stop bringing me plants!

- Miss Manners Judith Martin Please send your questions to Miss Manners at missmanner­s.com.

DEAR MISS MANNERS » I have a friend who continuall­y brings a potted flower whenever she comes to visit. Although I very much welcome her visits, I have a difficult time caring for plants and I end up struggling to keep them alive — a struggle that I would like to avoid.

The truth of the matter is that a gift of any type is unnecessar­y. Is there a courteous way of telling my friend, without hurting her feelings, that I do not want plants, and that anything else — or nothing at all — would be perfectly fine? GENTLE READER » Show her your dead plant. “I am afraid that I am hopeless when it comes to taking care of these. I wouldn't want our visits to be marred by blood on our mutual hands.”

If this inadverten­tly results in getting a lesson in plant care, well, you can thank Miss Manners for that later.

DEAR MISS MANNERS » At work, a graphic design position opened up and I mentioned it to a young person I knew, suggesting that she apply. She was studying that field in her college courses, and the position would help start her career. She got the job. We became “work friends” and things went well.

Later, when my daughter was getting married and wanted to have someone design her invitation­s, I suggested my young Work Friend. The design was lovely, my daughter paid her for the invitation­s and I thought that was that.

But a couple of weeks before the ceremony, Work Friend told me that she wanted me to get her and her husband invitation­s to the wedding. She really wanted to go to the ceremony.

I was taken aback by this request for these reasons: My daughter had only hired her to do a job; my daughter had not invited Work Friend and had never even suggested to me that she wanted to; and my daughter had never met Work Friend before the meeting about the invitation­s.

I gently stumbled around a bit, talking about how she was hired to do a job, profession­al relationsh­ips versus personal, etc., and did not comply with her request. I only mentioned it to my daughter after the wedding, and she agreed with me that the request was odd.

I felt like Work Friend seriously oversteppe­d her bounds in asking me to do this, and in the hurt feelings she displayed afterward. She became less of a friend and more just a coworker. I was left feeling that she really had expected me to step in and make that request (demand?) of my daughter. What could I have done better?

GENTLE READER » Clearly Work Friend was rude to try to procure an invitation, so your stumbling was warranted. But in her mind, your explanatio­n was rubbing in the fact that Work Friend was not actually Real Friend. And that is why she was insulted.

To lessen the offense, Miss Manners might have suggested instead: “I am afraid it is an intimate wedding.”

 ?? ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States