Flood of bankruptcies expected
WEST CHESTER » Many small businesses in the region will be getting financial relief from the CARES Act, which contains financial relief for American workers and small businesses, but it will not be enough for many of them, and they will need to declare bankruptcy.
David deBruin, a partner in
Gawthrop Greenwood’s Restructuring and Corporate Bankruptcy department, is expecting a flood of bankruptcy filings and out-ofcourt debt restructuring in the coming months.
“There are going to be a number of filings,” said deBruin. “The shift started with quite a few long-standing businesses ranging from multinational corporations to closely held family businesses, which needed assistance with cash-flow projections as well as negotiating new terms with lenders, vendors and employees. Now we’re beginning to see an uptick in ‘workout’ services, where we help businesses work with their current lenders to resolve a distressed or defaulted loan.”
There are 30 million small businesses in America and even though the country put $500 billion into forgivable loan programs, that still is not enough money to cover all those compa
nies’ losses, deBruin said.
During his 24 years in practice — in addition to representing distressed corporations in out-ofcourt debt restructurings, and Chapter 11 debtors-inpossession — deBruin has represented banks, lenders, investors, lessors, leaseholders, creditors, purchasers, vendors, creditor committees, Chapter 7 trustees and preference defendants in bankruptcy courts located in Delaware, Pennsylvania and New Jersey.
“Businesses across a wide swath of industries and in vastly different financial conditions are making very tough decisions about how to stretch cash on hand, substantially cut costs, refinance debt to avoid loan defaults and potentially reorganize,” says deBruin.
Michael Merlie, a practitioner of corporate and business law for over 25 years, has also represented creditors in bankruptcy matters, including obtaining relief from the automatic stay and successfully defending preference actions.
“These are daunting times for our region’s businesses and corporations. The shutdown of a huge segment of the economy caused by the COVID-19 pandemic has left most companies grappling with massive hits to their revenues,” said Merlie.
Over the last month, nearly 22 million Americans have filed unemployment claims as Americans continue to shelter in place. Economists estimate that the total number of Americans without a job could hit 47 million, or about a 32 percent unemployment rate. About 58 percent of Americans say they’ve already lost income because of he coronavirus crisis.
Merlie says the most high-profile signs of trouble began when one brickand-mortar mall staple, The Cheesecake Factory, said that it wouldn’t be able to make rent payments on all of its leases because of the drastic loss of business.
Many Fortune 500 companies have tapped billions of dollars in credit from banks in preparation for an uncertain future.
In addition, companies that depend heavily on inperson consumer spending are especially stressed by the economic fallout from the coronavirus pandemic. Traditional retailers — whose financial positions were already precarious due to the huge increase in e-commerce — are running into additional trouble, as a record number of people have filed for unemployment and even more people are forced to cut back on shopping and spending.
Then there is the psychological toll.
“The psychological interplay between a business and its bank in a workout of a distressed or defaulted loan involves many issues that go beyond the plain language of the loan documents and the supporting case law,” said deBruin. “There are often significantly conflicting emotional pressures inherent in a restructuring situation, which need to be recognized and diffused. However, in the ‘chess game’ of a restructuring, emotional and psychological issues may strongly influence both parties’ actions.”
Merlie says, generally, a bank will have well-documented loan agreements that provide for a myriad of remedies, although some are likely to be draconian and deserve considerable thought before being exercised because they can threaten the economic survival of the borrower.
“Couple that with the anxiety of ‘losing it all’ and one may begin to understand the psyche of the borrower approaching the restructuring process,” says deBruin. “Absent a negotiated out-of-court workout, the borrower may choose to file for bankruptcy protection.”
When the overall debt structure is complex and the lenders (and vendors) start vying over who gets paid first, a debtor may choose to seek protection in Federal Bankruptcy Court, where all the corporate debts can be renegotiated under the watch and approval of a Federal Bankruptcy Judge and the United States Trustee.
A Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing allows a debtor to seek new financing, sell off troublesome but profitable subsidiaries or underutilized assets, and close unprofitable stores, plants, or locations. A reorganization under Chapter 11 allows a business to catch its breath and ideally provides it with a fresh start.
Says Merlie, “Every credit situation is unique. The leverage and perspective each party brings to the table varies, and actions of creditors must be tailored to the particular situation, including the personality and background of the debtor.”
“I have absolutely no doubt we will get through this time period,” deBruin said. It’s impossible to read the tea leaves and see what that will look like, but there will be a lot of changes after we come out of this. It won’t be the end of days.”