At 6 months, time taking toll on hostages’ families
With no release deal on horizon, Israel grows more divided
JERUSALEM — It’s the last wish of a dying mother — to be with her daughter once more. But six months into Israel’s war against Hamas, time is running out for Liora Argamani, who hopes to stay alive long enough to see her kidnapped daughter come home.
“I want to see her one more time. Talk to her one more time,” said Argamani, 61, who has stage 4 brain cancer. “I don’t have a lot of time left in this world.”
Noa Argamani was abducted from a music festival Oct. 7 when Hamasled militants stormed into southern Israel, killing some 1,200 people and taking around 250 hostage. The video of her abduction was among the first to surface with images of her horrified face widely shared: Noa detained between two men on a motorcycle, one arm outstretched and the other held down as she screams, “Don’t kill me!”
There’s been little news about Noa, 26. But in mid-January, Hamas released a video of her in captivity. She appeared gaunt and under duress as she spoke about other hostages killed in airstrikes and frantically called on Israel to bring her and others home.
Half a year into Israel’s war, agonized families like the Argamanis are in a race against time.
In November, a weeklong cease-fire deal saw the release of more than 100 hostages. But the war is dragging on, with no end in sight and no serious hostage deal on the table. Israel says more than 130 hostages remain, with about a quarter of those believed dead, and divisions are deepening in the country over the best way to bring them home.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has vowed to both eliminate Hamas and bring all the hostages back, but he’s made little progress. He faces pressure to resign, and the U.S. has threatened to scale back its support over the humanitarian situation in Gaza.
Israelis are divided into two main camps: those who want the government to put the war on hold and free the hostages, and others who think the hostages are an unfortunate price to pay for eradicating Hamas.
“They have these two goals and the assessment of the type of risk they’re willing to take to get the hostages back — this is where you see divisions,” said Shmuel Rosner, a senior fellow at the Jewish People Policy Institute and analyst for Israeli public television station Kan News.
On-and-off negotiations mediated by Qatar, the United States and Egypt have yielded little result. If a viable deal emerges, decisions will become harder and the divisions sharper, Rosner said.
But for most families and friends whose loved ones are in captivity, there is no choice but to bring them home. Many are particularly concerned about the women held in Gaza and say, based on testimonies from freed hostages, they fear those remaining could be suffering from sexual abuse.
Yarden Gonen, whose 23-year-old sister, Romi, was also taken from the Oct. 7 music festival, criticized what she said was the government’s inaction.
“What are we fighting for?” she said. “What is more important than this?”
Outside an art installation mimicking the Gaza tunnels where some hostages are believed to be held, Romi’s mother said she can’t believe it’s been half a year, with much of the world wanting to forget or ignore such a horrible situation.
“We are doing everything we can so the world will not forget,” Merav Leshem Gonen said. “Every day we wake up and take a big breath, deep breath and continue walking, continue doing the things that will bring her back.”
When Yonatan Levi saw the video of his friend, Noa Argamani, in captivity, he said he could barely recognize the smart, free spirit of the woman who loved parties and traveling and was studying computer science.
“When I saw that video, I thought maybe she’s living physically but has died inside,” said Levi, who met Argamani during a diving course in the southern Israeli city of Eilat.
A few months before her abduction, Argamani asked Levi to help navigate insurance issues for her mom, he said. As an only child, she was a big part of her mother’s life and care, and she seemed hopeful she would be OK, Levi said.
But Liora Argamani’s cancer has worsened, according to a video released by the Hostages and Missing Families Forum.
The stress of missing a loved one is hard on the healthiest of people, and it will only exacerbate a condition like cancer, said Ofrit Shapira Berman, a psychoanalyst who heads a group of health professionals treating freed hostages, families and survivors.
“The fact that so much of her psychic energy is invested in her daughter’s trauma leaves her lesser chance to survive,” Berman said.