The News Herald (Willoughby, OH)

Helpful man poses a #MeToo riddle

- Amy Dickinson Contact Amy Dickinson via email at askamy@ amydickins­on.com.

DEAR AMY >> I like to think that I am a caring and sensitive man — one who respects women and appreciate­s the spirit of the #MeToo movement.

Therefore, a recent experience has me disturbed. I am looking for some objective feedback.

One recent evening, I was with a woman that I know well. We had drinks before, during and after dinner.

It became apparent to me that she was quite intoxicate­d and probably should head to bed to sleep it off. I helped her up the stairs to the bathroom. After a few minutes, when I heard the bathroom door open, I came back upstairs to check on her. This is when things got “tricky.”

She was naked, and she made strong sexual advances toward me.

I knew that the “right” thing to do was to help her get dressed and into bed for sleep, and then go on about my own business. But I was weak, partly due to my strong attraction to her. We engaged in sexual activity, and during the acts I believed there was a possibilit­y that the next day she would not remember (or at least she might not remember how things got started). Yet I continued, and for this I am feeling remorseful.

Have I committed “date rape”? Am I a “predator”?

If the situation came to a courtroom, or if I were a public figure, would people judge me to be a “bad” man?

And finally, Amy, does it matter that this woman is my wife of 25 years? — Wondering Husband

DEAR HUSBAND >> I hope this didn’t really happen; I’m assuming instead that your question might be a disingenuo­us and rude little riddle, designed to trip up an unsuspecti­ng reader.

However, let’s press on.

You ask for an objective opinion. Here’s mine:

Let’s establish at the outset that no, you are not a caring and sensitive man. No, you do not respect the #MeToo movement. That much is quite obvious.

Taking the scenario you describe at face value — yes, you sexually assaulted your wife. She was drunk; you were sober. She wasn’t able to consent to sex — not that you asked her.

No, you did not commit “date rape.” You did, however, commit “marital rape.” You pursued an incapacita­ted woman for the purpose of having sex with her. Yes, this makes you a predator.

Importantl­y, and unfortunat­ely — your wife is married to a man who thinks this is a clever and legitimate question worthy of some sort of debate. I genuinely feel sorry for her. You should be ashamed of yourself.

Turn in your good husband card. You are a cad.

DEAR AMY >> You ran a question from “Pay it Forward,” who was insulted when a stranger in line at the store offered to pick up their tab. “Pay” refused the gesture.

Here is my response: My wife of 40 years died last week. She died suddenly, during a routine medical procedure.

I couldn’t face another night eating alone, so I reserved a table at a favorite restaurant — an expensive gourmet place that my wife and I frequented.

After appropriat­e hugs and condolence­s from the staff, I was seated next to a social older couple who ordered what I was going to select. I asked about their order and the conversati­on turned to some things that we both had in common.

Eventually, I explained my lack of a dinner companion. We chatted amiably, friended each other on Facebook and they departed.

I motioned for my bill and found it has been taken care of by my newfound friends.

Their kindness and generosity made me tear up. (Of course, I reached out to them to thank them.)

My point is that the ability to accept an act of kindness is a lost art and it is this country’s most desperatel­y needed form of etiquette.

We can’t give kindness if we don’t learn how to accept it.

— Thomas

DEAR THOMAS >> My sincere condolence­s. You have attached the perfect lesson to accepting this generosity, and I think your story is going to inspire a lot of people to do the same. Connecting with others helps keep all of us afloat.

DEAR AMY >> Ah, your advice to “Middle Schooler” about dealing with testing jitters made me smile ... especially this part: “... imagine a big, friendly golden retriever sitting calmly beside you while you take your test.”

What a great image! I’m not in middle school, but I’m going to use it. —AFan

DEAR FAN >> Well, it works for me!

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States