The Punxsutawney Spirit

Judge suspends Michigan’s dormant 1931 abortion ban

- By Ed White

DETROIT (AP) — A judge on Tuesday suspended Michigan’s dormant, decades-old ban on abortion, which means the procedure would not be illegal in the state even if the U.S. Supreme Court overturned its historic Roe v. Wade decision.

The Michigan law, which makes it a crime to assist in an abortion, has been on the books since 1931. But it has had no practical effect since 1973 when the Supreme Court legalized abortion nationwide.

The court, however, could throw out that landmark ruling before July, leaving abortion issues for each state to decide.

Court of Claims Judge Elizabeth Gleicher granted a preliminar­y injunction sought by Planned Parenthood of Michigan, saying the abortion ban likely violates the Michigan Constituti­on.

“After 50 years of legal abortion in Michigan, there can be no doubt but that the right of personal autonomy and bodily integrity enjoyed by our citizens includes the right of a woman, in consultati­on with her physician, to terminate a pregnancy,” the judge said.

“From a constituti­onal standpoint, the right to obtain a safe medical treatment is indistingu­ishable from the right of a patient to refuse treatment,” Gleicher said.

Gleicher said other Michigan laws regulating abortion will remain in full effect. The injunction will stay in place while the judge makes a final decision in the months ahead or a higher court intervenes.

“No matter what happens at the Supreme Court, abortion access remains protected in Michigan while our full case proceeds to block this antiquated law once and for all,” said Dr. Sarah Wallett of Planned Parenthood.

The attorney general’s office typically defends against challenges to Michigan laws. But Attorney General Dana Nessel, a Democrat, said she would not defend or enforce the abortion ban. She, too, believes it is unconstitu­tional and welcomed the injunction.

Right to Life of Michigan and the Michigan Catholic Conference stepped in with legal briefs opposing Planned Parenthood, but they don’t have standing as formal parties in the case. It’s possible that the Republican-controlled Legislatur­e could file an appeal.

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer called the ruling a victory.

It “sends the message that Michigan’s 1931 law banning abortion, even in cases of rape or incest, should not go into effect even if Roe is overturned,” Whitmer, a Democrat, said. “It will help ensure that Michigan remains a place where women have freedom and control over their own bodies.”

In May, Politico published a leaked draft of a U.S. Supreme Court opinion. The document indicates the court could be poised to overturn Roe v. Wade.

The lawsuit by Planned Parenthood, which performs abortions, is one of two legal challenges in Michigan. Whitmer, who supports abortion rights, has asked the Michigan Supreme Court to bypass lower courts and declare the 91-year-old law unconstitu­tional. That effort is pending.

Both lawsuits preceded the leak of the draft opinion. But they’re examples of the scramble across the country as states prepare for the fall of Roe.

Gleicher, who also serves as chief judge on the Michigan Court of Appeals, informed the parties in April that she makes annual contributi­ons to Planned Parenthood and, as a lawyer, represente­d the organizati­on in a 1997 abortion case. She said she didn’t feel it should disqualify her.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States