The qualities of a good judge
As an attorney who has practiced as a litigator for more than 40 years, first in Houston, Texas, and since 1999 in northern New Mexico, I have had many an occasion during that time to ponder the qualities of a good trial court judge. We are extremely fortunate here in the 8th Judicial District (Taos County, Colfax County, and Union County) to have in Judge Melissa Kennelly a district court judge who has them all.
Judge Melissa Kennelly worked for me as an associate from June 2011 until July 2013, and her presence in my office and able assistance in my practice made those the most rewarding and enjoyable years in my entire practice. She demonstrated great skill in research, analysis and writing, and helped with and participated in bench trials and hearings. More important though, she was a reliable, steady and calm presence in my office; she was able to contribute ideas, strategies and solutions to problems, including administration and personnel matters. Seldom had I encountered an attorney who so impressed me with mature and professional demeanor, calm and steady temperament, incisive intelligence and collegiality.
When Judge Backus retired I strongly encouraged Melissa to apply for the position. The process of applying to be district judge is rigorous. A bipartisan commission, chaired by the Dean of the University of New Mexico Law School, checks academic records, disciplinary complaints, reviews references and interviews each candidate.
Judge Kennelly passed this process and was recommended as qualified to Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham. Judge Kennelly was appointed by our Governor, and has served honorably and well for the last year. Judge Kennelly is the judge who covers most of the court cases in Ratón and Clayton, and her commitment to the area east of the mountains includes having bought a house in Ratón, in which she lives during most weeks.
The judicial selection system in New Mexico requires a person appointed by the governor to run in the next election against any lawyer, who has practiced six years or more and wants the job. Judge Kennelly faces three opponents who want the job. None of them have ever been recommended as qualified by a judicial selection commission.
A good judge should have the following qualities: patience, open-mindedness, courtesy, tact, firmness, understanding, compassion, humility and common sense. These qualities should be shown consistently over time. Judge Kennelly has in the years I’ve known her personified these qualities.
I strongly recommend you vote to keep Judge Melissa Kennelly as division 2 district judge.
Carol Neelley lives in Santa Fe.