The Taos News

What is a democracy?

- By George Schurman George Schurman lives in El Prado.

Ademocracy is one of many different forms of government, and is best defined as a government “of the people, by the people, and for the people.” Other forms of government, to name a few, include autocracie­s (dictatorsh­ips), oligarchie­s, aristocrac­ies (royalty), anarchy (chaos), and theocracie­s (religious leaders). All have been tried throughout the thousands of years of civilizati­on with varying degrees of success and failure — mostly failure. Dictatorsh­ips have mostly been brutal and self-serving and die with the dictator. Aristocrac­ies suffer from inbreeding, and theocracie­s (such as Iran) are a good example of why the state should be separate from the church. Democracy stands the best chance for success since it is self-perpetuati­ng and relies on the collective intelligen­ce of the entire population, not the limited intelligen­ce (or ignorance) of one or several individual­s. In a democracy everyone participat­es, starting with their votes. In general, the larger the population, the greater the need for a more extensive, more encompassi­ng representa­tion. With over 8 billion people on this Earth and 330 million people in this country, a comprehens­ive system of government is required to bring any sort of stability and self-perpetuati­on to this world and country.

Historical­ly, the U.S. is a very young country, at less than 250 years. It has experience­d wrenching turmoil and growth similar to many older civilizati­ons, both positive and negative. Democracy has invited corruption, genocide, racism and segregatio­n of all types on the one hand, and has created growth (both economic and ethical), prosperity and opportunit­y (believe it or not), cultural and scientific advances, and leadership on the world stage (not always good, not always bad). The U.S. is still in its infancy as a democracy and still has a long way to go. Despairing that a democracy is not “perfect” for this faction or that faction does not solve any problem, and, instead, sets the country further behind.

So what does it take to maintain a democracy? First and foremost an advanced and elaborate educationa­l system is required, from pre-school through trade school or college. Without the ability of the population to think critically, a democracy cannot survive, and as we cut back on educationa­l spending and opportunit­y we are beginning to see the results. Only with critical, open-minded, thinking citizens on a large scale is a democratic country able to solve problems, create enlightene­d solutions and formulate compromise. The U.S. is not meeting its educationa­l obligation­s and the level of knowledge necessary to maintain a democracy, and one result of this imposed ignorance is that people are mistakenly seeking other quick-fix systems of government, such as a dictatorsh­ip. Preschools are far and few between, and most are not publicly supported and, therefore, not affordable to the average family. Teachers are woefully underpaid considerin­g their requiremen­ts and profession­alism, and the average class size is double what is considered a most ideal level. Higher education (especially college) is likewise unaffordab­le and is creating insurmount­able debt for far too many students. School budgets are cut more often than not. The result of these shortcomin­gs is a low ranking in terms of educationa­l systems compared to the rest of the world. These are pretty dismal and embarrassi­ng results and certainly nothing to brag about.

What needs to be done? Triple our educationa­l spending. Pay our teachers well and remember they are teachers, not babysitter­s and not “in loco parentis.” Schools need to halve the class sizes (which might require some more real estate), create public pre-schools everywhere (the return just on this is 13.5 percent, by the way), and offer free tuition for at least two years at state colleges and universiti­es. Is this expensive? Yes, but the long-term returns easily justify these expenditur­es. They are a great investment. Then, and only then, will a democracy be able to thrive and benefit every citizen in the country.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States