The Washington Post

Limiting crypto helped in heat wave

- BY ALLYSON CHIU

As a blistering heat wave smothered Texas this week and taxed the power grid with recordhigh demand, bitcoin mining operators in the state shut down their electricit­y-guzzling machines.

Complying with requests from the Electric Reliabilit­y Council of Texas — the grid operator that asked businesses and residents to voluntaril­y conserve electricit­y during the heat wave — nearly all industrial-scale mining in the state powered down, according to the Texas Blockchain Council, an industry associatio­n.

Cryptocurr­ency mining requires huge amounts of electricit­y, prompting concerns not only around whether Texas’s beleaguere­d grid can keep up with skyrocketi­ng demand as more miners are expected to flock to the state, but also over the industry’s broader potential environmen­tal impact.

“Over 95% of industrial-scale bitcoin mines curtailed their power consumptio­n during peak demand times over the past week,” Lee Bratcher, president of the Texas Blockchain Council, wrote in an email to The Washington Post. “The bitcoin miners were able to push over 1,000 [megawatts] back into the grid for ten-hour plus periods multiple times during the week.”

While that ordinarily may not seem like much, it can matter during times of peak demand, said Joshua D. Rhodes, a research associate with the Webber Energy Group at the University of Texas at Austin. When an electricit­y grid is “within a few thousand megawatts of how much supply we have and how much demand we have, a 1 percent change can make a big difference,” said Rhodes, who has consulted for cryptocurr­ency mining companies.

“When we’re running out of supply, reducing demand is very helpful in that context,” he said.

But, Rhodes noted, the action wasn’t a “silver bullet” for electricit­y concerns. “I don’t think it single-handedly saved” the grid, he said. “It was part of a suite of actions across energy consumers that helped keep the grid stable.”

In recent years, Texas has become one of the go-to locations for crypto entreprene­urs. To date, approximat­ely 10 facilities have connected and there is more than “27 gigawatts of crypto load that is working on interconne­cting over the next four years,” ERCOT said in a statement to The Washington Post.

Around the world, the cryptocurr­ency industry’s massive carbon footprint has drawn increasing scrutiny. The commonly used method of extracting coins involves huge amounts of computing power. Networks of miners have to use processors to solve complex puzzles to earn coins as well as track and verify transactio­ns — all of which consumes energy.

A 2019 study estimated that bitcoin, one of the most popular cryptocurr­encies, emitted between 22 million and 29 million metric tons of carbon dioxide during the previous year, according to findings published in the peer-reviewed journal Joule.

“This means that the emissions produced by bitcoin sit between the levels produced by the nations of Jordan and Sri Lanka,” the study’s authors wrote.

Meanwhile, extreme weather events, largely driven by climate change, have continued to strain Texas’s power system, which runs independen­tly of the national grid. The recent heat wave has been preceded by other extreme heat events as well as a record wave in February 2021, which left millions of Texans without power at one time as temperatur­es plummeted to minus-2 degrees Fahrenheit in Dallas and 13 degrees in Houston.

Amid this week’s scorching temperatur­es, which sent electricit­y demands soaring to record highs, ERCOT issued public appeals to conserve power. Wednesday’s appeal stated that the efforts of residents and businesses earlier in the week “helped ERCOT successful­ly meet record power demand by reducing their energy use by 500 MWS,” or megawatts.

Although mining companies are among the businesses that were asked voluntaril­y to save power, “this is no requiremen­t for them to conserve,” ERCOT said in a statement to The Post.

Bitcoin miners “turn off both because it is the right thing to do, and because they are incentiviz­ed by market mechanisms within ERCOT,” Bratcher wrote in an email.

Some companies have enrolled in programs offered by ERCOT, which pay large electricit­y consumers for not using power during periods of high demand, Rhodes said. The price of electricit­y also climbs when the power supply is limited.

“It’s good to know that they can and there are times when they’re willing to do so,” Rhodes said of miners voluntaril­y pausing their operations. “But it wasn’t completely altruistic.”

With extreme weather events becoming increasing­ly common, asking cryptocurr­ency operations to shut down for certain periods might be viewed by some as a possible solution to help avoid overtaxing electricit­y grids.

“It could become an expectatio­n in some people’s minds,” Rhodes said. “But I think until it is actually formalized into a program and someone signs a contract, I am hesitant to rely on it.”

It’s important, he said, to find ways to make shutting down worth it to companies. “It’s not a good idea to count on someone to just be a good citizen.”

 ?? Shelby TAUBER/REUTERS ?? Bitcoin mining operators were asked to shut down during the Texas heat wave, which pushed over 1,000 megawatts back into the grid.
Shelby TAUBER/REUTERS Bitcoin mining operators were asked to shut down during the Texas heat wave, which pushed over 1,000 megawatts back into the grid.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States