The Washington Post

New footage sheds light on election challenge

Surveillan­ce video shows pro-trump consultant­s visiting Ga. county office

- BY EMMA BROWN AND JON SWAINE

Technology consultant­s who sought evidence that Donald Trump’s 2020 defeat was fraudulent made multiple visits to a county elections office in rural Georgia in the weeks after an alleged post-election breach of voting equipment there that is the subject of a criminal investigat­ion.

Surveillan­ce video reviewed by The Washington Post shows that the consultant­s, Doug Logan and Jeffrey Lenberg, made two visits in January 2021 to the elections office in Coffee County, about 200 miles south of Atlanta. Lenberg made an additional five visits on his own. The two men are under investigat­ion for separate alleged breaches of voting machines in Michigan.

The footage also shows that earlier in January, Cathy Latham, a teacher and then-chairwoman of the county Republican Party, greeted a group of outside data forensics experts when they ar

rived at the elections office shortly before noon on the day of the alleged breach. Latham has said in sworn testimony that she taught a full day of school that day and visited the elections office briefly after classes ended. She was one of 16 Republican­s who signed certificat­es declaring Trump the rightful winner of the 2020 election as part of the “fake elector” scheme now under investigat­ion by federal and state prosecutor­s.

The new video adds to the picture of the alleged breach in Coffee County on Jan. 7, 2021, and reveals for the first time the later visits by Logan and Lenberg. It also provides further indication­s of links between various efforts to overturn the election, including what once appeared to be disparate attempts to access and copy election system data in the wake of Trump’s loss.

Experts have expressed concern that such efforts could expose details of voting systems’ hardware and software that are intended to be tightly controlled, potentiall­y aiding hackers who might seek to alter the results of a future election. Data copied from elections systems in other states has been published online. Georgia state officials and voting-machine makers have downplayed the risk, pointing to safeguards that they say protect the systems from tampering.

The Post reported last month that a data forensics firm hired by pro-trump lawyer Sidney Powell copied software and data from the Dominion Voting Systems machines used by Coffee County. The Georgia Bureau of Investigat­ion has said it is investigat­ing the matter.

Details of the Coffee County incident have come to light largely because of a flurry of subpoenas and deposition­s by plaintiffs in a long-running federal lawsuit against Georgia authoritie­s over the security of the state’s elections. Emails and other records they obtained from the data forensics firm, Atlanta-based SullivanSt­rickler, showed that the Coffee episode was part of a coordinate­d multistate effort to access voting equipment in a hunt for evidence that the election was rigged.

The plaintiffs, including several Georgia voters and the nonprofit Coalition for Good Governance, obtained the new surveillan­ce video in response to a subpoena to county authoritie­s and provided it to The Post.

The security footage shows only the exterior of the office’s entrance area, and it is not clear what the consultant­s Logan and Lenberg did inside.

Latham “would not and has not knowingly been involved in any impropriet­y in any election,” Robert D. Cheeley, her lawyer, said in a statement to The Post. She “did not authorize or participat­e in any ballot scanning efforts, computer imaging or any similar activity in Coffee County in January 2021.”

Logan and Lenberg did not respond to messages seeking comment for this report.

David Cross, a lawyer who represents some of the plaintiffs in the civil case, said the additional visits raise questions about why the two men returned. “The biggest concern that we have is future elections,” said Cross, whose clients are pressing Georgia authoritie­s to replace the state’s ballotmark­ing machines with handmarked paper ballots.

Logan and Lenberg have played roles in the multistate pursuit of voting machines by Trump supporters. Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel (D) has asked for a special prosecutor to decide whether to pursue charges against them and others on allegation­s they conspired to unlawfully access elections equipment in three counties there last year. Logan and Lenberg also provided affidavits as expert witnesses in a post-election lawsuit in Antrim County, Mich., after a judge granted Sullivanst­rickler access to Dominion Voting Systems machines there.

Sullivanst­rickler previously said it would be “fully cooperativ­e” with investigat­ors examining the Coffee County matter and is confident it has done nothing wrong. The firm has said it acted in good faith and on instructio­ns from licensed attorneys.

Sullivanst­rickler declined to comment for this article beyond its original statement.

The new surveillan­ce footage shows three Sullivanst­rickler employees arriving at the Coffee elections office at 11:42 a.m. on Jan. 7.

Latham had arrived five minutes earlier, the footage shows. She greeted the Sullivanst­rickler team and led them inside. Shortly before 1 p.m., a fourth employee from the firm arrived.

In her deposition last month, taken by plaintiffs in the long-running civil case, Latham said she recalled having gone to the Coffee County elections office for “just a few minutes” that day, arriving sometime after 3:48 p.m. when she received a text from Misty Hampton, then the county elections supervisor, that said: “Going great so far.”

Asked during the deposition whether it would have been possible for her to go to the election office during work hours, Latham answered: “I mean, I taught a full schedule, I didn’t have a planning period, so I can’t remember.”

Records filed in the civil case last week also show that an attorney for Sullivanst­rickler described Latham as the “primary point of contact in coordinati­ng and facilitati­ng” the firm’s work in Coffee County.

The footage shows Latham entering the building before noon, then leaving at 1:26 p.m. She returned several minutes after Hampton’s 3:48 p.m. text and then finally departed after 6 p.m., it shows. The building has a side door that is not shown in the footage.

“While Mrs. Latham does not pretend to remember the details of all that occurred on that specific date more than a year and a half ago, she does remember going to the Elections Office after teaching school on January 7, 2021 to check in on some voter review panels from the runoff election, and she truthfully testified to those facts,” Cheeley, her lawyer, told The Post.

The Sullivanst­rickler team left the building at 7:43 p.m., more than 21/ hours after the office’s

2 regular closing time, the footage shows. Hampton immediatel­y followed.

The data obtained from Coffee County by Sullivanst­rickler included copies of virtually every component of the county voting system, including the central tabulation server, according to an inventory obtained by the plaintiffs through discovery. The firm billed Powell $26,000 for the day’s work, an invoice shows.

Hampton previously told The Post that she allowed a team of outsiders into her office after the 2020 vote so they could prove “that this election was not done true and correct.”

Hampton and attorneys for Coffee County did not respond to messages seeking comment.

The new surveillan­ce footage shows that on Jan. 18, 11 days after Sullivanst­rickler completed its work in Coffee County, Logan and Lenberg arrived at the elections office with Hampton at 4:20 p.m.

Logan, 42, was chief executive of the security firm Cyber Ninjas, which was hired by GOP state lawmakers in Arizona to hunt for fraud in the 2020 vote there. The firm’s review found Trump lost to Joe Biden in Arizona by an even greater margin than the certified result. Logan, of Sarasota, Fla., announced earlier this year that he had shuttered the company.

Lenberg, 66, lives in Tijeras, N.M., and previously worked in technical roles at a private laboratory operated for the National Nuclear Security Administra­tion. A résumé for Lenberg filed in the Antrim court case stated that he has held high-level security clearances and that his past work included “developing ways to break in (if possible) to what were considered to be secure systems.”

When the pair arrived at the Coffee County elections office, both were carrying backpacks, and Lenberg brought snacks and energy drinks. Hampton and the two consultant­s were recorded leaving the building nearly four hours later. Logan and Lenberg returned to the elections office shortly before 9 a.m. the next morning, the footage shows, and exited after 6 p.m.

Six days later, Jan. 25, Lenberg was again recorded arriving at the elections office. He left nearly three hours later, then returned for shorter visits on each of the following four days, the video shows. On one occasion, he was carrying the box for a ring light system typically used to illuminate subjects of video recordings.

Lenberg was part of an election review team in New Mexico that last month published a report featuring an image of what it called “a system log from a Dominion machine in Georgia.” At a public hearing of the Otero County Commission earlier this year, Lenberg said he had obtained “data from multiple counties” in Georgia and that he met with Hampton of Coffee County.

The Post has reported that, according to computer logs obtained by the plaintiffs, an account in Logan’s name had accessed Coffee County data on Sullivanst­rickler’s file-sharing system.

In spring 2021, after Hampton resigned, Logan’s business card was found on her desk by her successor, James Barnes. Barnes sent a copy of the card to the secretary of state’s office, expressing alarm in light of the fact that the Justice Department had raised concerns about the ballot review led by Cyber Ninjas in Arizona, according to an email obtained by The Post. An investigat­or in the secretary of state’s office was directed to follow up with county officials and “verify what if any contact cyber ninjas had with any election equipment,” emails show. Barnes said in a deposition that state officials never contacted him.

Cross, the attorney for the plaintiffs, said at that point state authoritie­s should have asked county officials for surveillan­ce footage to determine who had been in the office and when. “They would have had a year and a half before a major midterm election to figure this out,” he said.

A spokesman for Secretary of State Brad Raffensper­ger (R) did not directly address questions from The Post about the agency’s response to Barnes’s concern or say whether the agency sought the security-camera footage at the time. Raffensper­ger has said publicly that after the election his staff devoted time to pursuing every tip of alleged voter fraud. His office has told the court that it began investigat­ing the Coffee County matter in February 2022, when allegation­s of the breach first became an issue in the long-running lawsuit. The Georgia Bureau of Investigat­ion said it has been working with Raffensper­ger’s office and opened the criminal case Aug. 15.

“We will hold all who acted in bad faith and broke the law to account,” said Gabriel Sterling, interim deputy secretary of state.

The new court records show that local elections board official Eric Chaney acknowledg­ed in a deposition last month that he, too, was at the Coffee County elections office on Jan. 7, 2021. Chaney previously told The Post he was not to his knowledge present when anyone “illegally accessed” the Coffee County server.

In the same deposition, Chaney responded to questions about the effort to copy Dominion Voting equipment by citing his Fifth Amendment right to avoid self-incriminat­ion. The video footage shows that Chaney arrived at the elections office shortly before 11 a.m. that day and left shortly before 8 p.m. Chaney and his lawyer did not respond to messages seeking comment.

 ?? ??
 ?? IMAGES OBTAINED By THE WASHINGTON POST ?? ABOVE: Coffee County GOP Chairwoman Cathy Latham is seen in surveillan­ce video leading three employees of Sullivanst­rickler into the county’s election office on Jan. 7, 2021. The data forensics firm was hired to access elections data. LEFT: Consultant­s Jeffrey Lenberg, left, and Doug Logan enter the election office Jan. 18.
IMAGES OBTAINED By THE WASHINGTON POST ABOVE: Coffee County GOP Chairwoman Cathy Latham is seen in surveillan­ce video leading three employees of Sullivanst­rickler into the county’s election office on Jan. 7, 2021. The data forensics firm was hired to access elections data. LEFT: Consultant­s Jeffrey Lenberg, left, and Doug Logan enter the election office Jan. 18.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States