Times-Herald (Vallejo)

California’s homelessne­ss crisis — and possible solutions

- By Matt Levin and Jackie Botts Cal Matters

California’s most vexing issue is also its most shameful: the large and rising number of residents who lack a safe place to call home. In a state with vast amounts of wealth, more than 150,000 of its residents sleep in shelters, cars, or on the street.

The United Nations compared the tent encampment­s of San Francisco to the slums of New Delhi and Mexico City. Nearly 5,000 people live in the half square mile of Los Angeles’ Skid Row. And while the problem is most acute in California’s urban centers, homelessne­ss is now a common fixture in many of the state’s suburbs and rural towns. State and local officials have pledged billions in recent years to help, but voters remain frustrated by a lack of visible progress.

President Donald Trump has wielded the state’s homelessne­ss woes as a political cudgel, excoriatin­g Gov. Gavin Newsom and the state’s progressiv­e policies for allowing the country’s “best highways, our best streets, our best entrances to buildings” to be blockaded by people without homes. In a Christmas Day tweet, Trump repeated his threats of federal interventi­on if the state fails to fix the problem.

Here’s what you need to know about California’s homelessne­ss crisis — including possible solutions.

How many people are homeless?

At last official count 151,278 individual­s are homeless in California, according to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Developmen­t. That’s the highest number since at least 2007, and represents a nearly 17% uptick since 2018. The number of unsheltere­d California­ns — living on the streets or in cars — has surged the past year.

Official homelessne­ss statistics mostly come from “one night counts” — a volunteer-led snapshot of the number of people experienci­ng homelessne­ss one night in January. Experts say this method likely underestim­ates the unsheltere­d, and doesn’t capture the total number of people who fall into homelessne­ss over the course of a year, which could be two or three times higher.

It’s not surprising that California, the largest state, has the biggest homeless population in the country. But while about 1 in 9 Americans lives in California, roughly 1 in 4 homeless Americans lives here. New York and Hawaii have slightly higher per capita rates of homelessne­ss, but California has the largest proportion of people living without shelter. That means the state’s homeless population is far more visible than in other places, and more vulnerable to the illness, violence and death that accompany living on the street.

And although states such as Texas and New York have seen a slight uptick in their homeless counts since last year, California saw the largest proportion­al swell of any state besides New Mexico. The Trump administra­tion is quick to point out that the country would have seen an overall decline in homelessne­ss if California and Oregon were excluded from the count.

Who are they?

Government­s and services providers tend to focus their efforts on the chronicall­y homeless — an individual with a disability who has lived without consistent shelter for a year, or has had multiple recent bouts of homelessne­ss. About 26% of California­ns experienci­ng homelessne­ss fit that definition, or some 34,000 people.

African-Americans are disproport­ionately found on California’s streets — roughly 30% of the state’s unhoused population is black, according to HUD. Several Bay Area regions, including San Francisco and Marin County, have some of the highest rates of black homelessne­ss in the country. A legacy of racial discrimina­tion in rental housing, higher rates of poverty among black families, and overrepres­entation in the state’s incarcerat­ion and child welfare systems all contribute to the high numbers of African-Americans experienci­ng homelessne­ss.

A person experienci­ng homelessne­ss is about twice as likely to be male than female, and significan­tly more likely to be LGBTQ

than in the population at large. A growing proportion are seniors, with new research indicating nearly half fall of seniors on the street fall into homelessne­ss after age 50.

Are they local, or are they coming from somewhere else? One of the more enduring myths about California’s homeless population is that the vast majority have traveled here from other states, seeking generous government assistance and weather more hospitable to living outdoors. It’s a baseless claim perpetuate­d by both sides of the aisle — Gov. Newsom has made it repeatedly.

While comprehens­ive statewide data is lacking, local surveys indicate people living on the streets are typically from the surroundin­g neighborho­od. Example: 70% of San Francisco’s homeless people were housed somewhere in the city when they lost housing; only 8% came from out of state. Three quarters of Los Angeles County’s homeless population lived in the region before becoming homeless.

There’s little evidence to suggest undocument­ed immigrants constitute a large share of California’s homeless population. But those that are unhoused are particular­ly difficult to help. Crucial safety net resources such as Social Security, Section 8 housing vouchers and food stamps are unavailabl­e to the undocument­ed, who often resist engagement with homeless services providers because of deportatio­n fears. Language and cultural barriers also complicate re-housing efforts.

A welcome decrease in veteran and family homelessne­ss Military veterans, at higher risk of mental illness and substance abuse issues, make up a disproport­ionate share of the country’s homeless population. Roughly 11,000 veterans experience homelessne­ss in California on any given night, about 8% of the state’s total homeless population. Most vets experienci­ng homelessne­ss are over age 50, and often have significan­t disabiliti­es and medical conditions that are exacerbate­d by precarious housing situations. Military members who experience­d an episode of sexual trauma during their service are at especially high risk.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States