Reader challenges Amy’s past advice

DEAR READERS » Every year I step away from my daily column to work on other creative projects. I’ve gathered some topical “Best Of” columns from 10 years ago. I’ll be back in two weeks with fresh columns.

DEAR AMY » You regularly condone and even encourage sex without the benefit of marriage.

I wonder if you have ever considered how many of society’s problems can be traced back to this. Please consider for a moment what the world would be like if sex occurred only inside of marriage.

The number of unwanted pregnancies would be decimated. Abortion would be eliminated. Few, if any, children would grow up in a single-parent home. Imagine what would happen to the welfare system! What if almost everyone grew up in stable, two-parent homes? It boggles the mind, doesn’t it?

— K

DEAR K » Getting married does not prevent children from growing up in single-parent homes. People have been marrying and dissolving their marriages for a long time.

Many two-parent homes are unstable, and some stable families are led by two parents who, until recently, couldn’t legally marry.

Consenting adults can and will have sex regardless of what you

(or I) say. It’s not my business, and as long as it doesn’t injure or harm anyone, involve the kids or break up another relationship or family, it shouldn’t be your business, either.

March 2010

DEAR AMY » I am a 32-year-old single woman with many married friends. Recently, I went to a concert with some couples, and also a married man who didn’t bring his wife.

In the back seat of a car on the way home, he tried to kiss me. I pulled away. The next day when he sent me an email saying he had a good time, I didn’t respond.

I saw him with his family at a recent dinner party. He said he wanted to have coffee sometime, and that he’d like to get to know me better. I was polite and hoped nothing would come of it, but he recently emailed me and asked to get a drink.

He is a nice person. I don’t want to assume he wants to have an affair. How do I respond?

— Troubled Single

DEAR TROUBLED » You say he’s a “nice person,” but nice (and married) men don’t try to force kisses on disinterested women in the back seats of cars, and nice men don’t do end runs around their wives and kids at a dinner party.

In those old movies I love, this guy would be called “a prize heel.”

August 2010