Times-Herald (Vallejo)

How president could shutter the US-Mexico border

- By Colleen Long

President Joe Biden has made some strong claims over the past few days about shutting down the U.S.-Mexico border as he tries to salvage a border deal in Congress that would also unlock money for Ukraine.

The deal had been in the works for months and seemed to be nearing completion in the Senate before it began to fall apart, largely because Republican presidenti­al front-runner Donald Trump doesn't want it to happen.

“A bipartisan bill would be good for America and help fix our broken immigratio­n system and allow speedy access for those who deserve to be here, and Congress needs to get it done,” Biden said over the weekend. “It'll also give me, as president, the emergency authority to shut down the border until it could get back under control. If that bill were the law today, I'd shut down the border right now and fix it quickly.”

A look at what Biden meant, and the political and policy considerat­ions at play:

Where is Biden's tough talk coming from?

Biden wants continued funding for Ukraine in the face of Russia's invasion. Senate Republican­s had initially said they would not consider more money for Kyiv unless it was combined with a deal to manage the border.

As the talks have progressed, Biden has come to embrace efforts to reach a bipartisan border security deal after years of gridlock on overhaulin­g the immigratio­n system. But his statement that he would shut down the border “right now” if Congress passed the proposed deal is more about politics than policy.

He is seeking to disarm criticism of his handling of migration at the border as immigratio­n becomes an increasing matter of concern to Americans in the leadup to the presidenti­al election.

Would the border really shut down under the deal?

No. Trade would continue, and people who are citizens and legal residents could continue to go back and forth.

Biden is referencin­g an expulsion authority being negotiated by the lawmakers that would automatica­lly kick in on days when illegal crossings reached more than 5,000 over a five-day average across the Southern border, currently seeing as many as 10,000 crossings per day. The authority shuts down asylum screenings for those who cross illegally. Migrants could still apply at ports of entry until crossings dipped below 3,750 per day. But these are estimates. The final tally hasn't been ironed out.

There's also an effort to change how asylum cases are processed. Right now, it takes several years for a case to be resolved and in the meantime, many migrants are released into the country to wait. Republican­s see that as one reason that additional migrants are motivated to come to the U.S.

The goal would be to shrink the resolution time to six months. It would also raise the standards for which migrants can apply for asylum in the first place. The standard right now is broad by design so that potential asylum seekers aren't left out, but critics argue the system is being abused.

Didn't Trump also threaten to shut down the border?

Yes. Trump vowed to “shut down” the U.S-Mexico border entirely — including to trade and traffic — in an effort to force Mexico to do more to stem the flow of migrants. He didn't follow through, though. But the talk was heavily criticized by Democrats who said it was draconian and xenophobic. The closest Trump came was during the pandemic, when he used emergency authoritie­s to severely limit asylum. But trade and traffic still continued.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States