Tempting Fate

Meet the couples brave enough to pack their bags for Temptation Island (airing in October on USA)

Ashley Goldson & Rick Fleur

After four years of highs and lows,

Goldson, 30, is ready to find out if

Fleur, 32, is finally ready to settle down. She believes they’re meant to be, and he says he loves her — but after growing up in a strict household, he wants to enjoy life and have fun. Can she fully accept him for who he is, or will his wandering eye cause her to find someone else?

David Benavidez & Kate Griffith

At 34, Griffith is sure she wants

to be with Benavidez, 28, especially

after three years together. She’s ready for marriage and kids; he’s afraid to be vulnerable and has some walls up. The pair promise they’ve been faithful to each other, but that hasn’t always been the case with others in the past: She cheated on an ex-husband, and he stepped out on an ex-girlfriend.

Ashley Howland & Casey Starchak

A year and a half ago, Howland, 25,

met party boy Starchak, 26, on a dating app. What started as a fling turned serious, but the pair, who recently moved in together in DeLand, Fla., struggle with trust and commitment. Her past makes her wary, and he can’t help but think about the single life he gave up for her. (Sensing a theme?)

Gavin Rocker & Esonica Veira

The former pageant queen, 29,

has had a tough time trusting her boyfriend of more than a year ever since he admitted to cheating on her. But Rocker, 26, doesn’t want to be punished for his past mistakes. While she figures out whether she can truly forgive him, Rocker has to decide whether he’s ready to commit for good and give Veira the life she wants.