Military draft could expand

Mandatory registration may extend to women

ARLINGTON, Va. – Three years ago, Congress created a commission to help it answer a pair of questions: Is the Selective Service System, which requires 18-year-old men to register for a potential military draft, working?

If so, should it be expanded to include women?

The panel, more than halfway through its work, is asking even bigger questions.

Should draft registration be mandatory, voluntary or eliminated?

Should it target people with specific technical, medical or language skills, in addition to combat capability?

And should compulsory service be limited to the military, or should it include other forms of community service?

The National Commission on

Military, National, and Public

Service will deliver an interim report

Wednesday that hints at the breadth of its charge but gives few clues as to how it’s going to resolve the most controversial issues.

“Personally, I don’t think we will remain with the status quo,” commission Chairman Joe Heck said. “But where we end up on the spectrum is yet to be determined.”

Heck, a retired brigadier general and Republican former congressman from Nevada, called the question of whether women should be required to register for the Selective Service on turning 18 “visceral.”

“When we pose this question to people, it’s not like they say, ‘Oh, let me stop and think for a minute.’ They have an answer,” he said. “Either it’s yes, women should have to register just on the basis of equality, or no, women should not have to register because they have a different role in American society.”

In 2017, the Pentagon argued in favor of keeping the Selective Service system – and expanding it to include women.

“It would appear imprudent to exclude approximately 50 percent of the population – the female half – from availability for the draft in the case of a national emergency,” the Pentagon

“Personally, I don’t think we will remain with the status quo.” Joe Heck National Commission on Military, National, and Public Service

said in the report, which was released under the Freedom of Information Act.

The military said it’s committed to an all-volunteer force and doesn’t plan to implement a draft.

The commission’s review is the most expansive examination of the draft in U.S. history. Its conclusions are only advisory.

Congress has been divided. Lawmakers created the commission in 2016 after the House of Representatives refused to go along with a Senate proposal, supported by both conservative defense hawks and liberal feminists, to expand the draft to women.

President Barack Obama, in his last weeks in office, came out in favor of a gender-neutral draft in response to a question from USA TODAY.

Congress, unable to resolve the issue, did what it often does: created a commission to study the question.

With a multiyear budget of $15 million, the 15-member panel is immune to the partial government shutdown.

The commission is taking on a longstanding debate.

President Franklin D. Roosevelt, citing a shortage of nurses, proposed drafting women in his 1945 State of the Union Address.

The draft was suspended at the end of the Vietnam War in 1973. When President Jimmy Carter reinstated draft registration in 1980, he proposed adding women. Congress disagreed.

In 1981, the Supreme Court decided 6-3 that male-only draft registration was constitutional because women weren’t eligible for most combat roles.

Last year, a federal judge in Houston ruled that the high court precedent might no longer apply because “now, women can serve in combat roles.”

That decision kept alive a lawsuit brought by the National Coalition for Men, which represents two men challenging the sex-based draft.

“We take no position on whether there should or should not be Selective Service,” said the men’s lawyer, Marc Angelucci. “

“What we are concerned about is the sex discrimination against men. And we oppose that whether or not there’s a draft.”