USA TODAY International Edition

Opposing view: We weren't smart. Amazon played us.

- Michael Gianaris

Excitement was in the air. New York won Amazon’s competitio­n, which pitted states against one another to extract the most generous subsidy package. While some rejoiced over the news, our aging subway system continued to crumble, Queens parents fought over scarce kindergart­en seats, and housing costs skyrockete­d. In an era of historic income inequality, granting massive subsidies to a very wealthy corporatio­n does not mean we were smart: It means we were played.

While many localities went out of their way to offer various benefits to Amazon, in the end it chose the most predictabl­e, logical locations for its corporate offices: the Washington, D.C., metro area and New York City. With access to large government and financial institutio­ns, an unmatched talent pool and exciting neighborho­ods attracting the best and the brightest from across the globe, it was unnecessar­y for New York to offer $3 billion for Amazon to choose what was already its most desirable location, an opinion shared by former Mayor Mike Bloomberg.

This fight is not just about Amazon but about the reckoning our nation faces regarding long discredite­d economic developmen­t policies. We should be well past the trickle-down theory of showering the very rich with taxpayer dollars in hopes of getting some back for working people.

Our money is better spent investing directly in our future: functionin­g mass transit, thriving schools, affordable housing.

We should not need to pay massive corporatio­ns to bring their largess to our communitie­s — let us build that future ourselves.

We are at a critical inflection point. Continuing to subsidize companies like Amazon puts the wants of the wealthy before the priorities of the people. New York can be the biggest loser in this cynical game, or we can lead the way to a more promising future. It is time we make the right choice.

Michael Gianaris, a Democrat, is deputy leader of the New York Senate. His district includes Amazon’s proposed location in Long Island City, Queens.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States